Quote:
Originally Posted by simms3_redux
Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but the MMPT is not going to include Amtrak. It will essentially expand the services and the architecture/efficiency of the current 5 Point MARTA station by adding busses and cabs, and long-term eventually office space and public space. I think it would eventually connect to the planned commuter rail line heading south as that would share track with Norfolk Southern, but that is still a pipe dream at this point.
The whole premise of the MMPT is essentially a waste as I have seen it proposed and DT office is not even an investment anyone can consider at this point. Norfolk Southern still uses the tracks that could connect Amtrak to the MMPT and viable solutions so far as I have read have not been reached. Passenger trains would remain north of the CBD either in current location or somewhere not too far.
|
Clarification: NS actually is on board with the project and has reiterated its commitment in the last ~12 months. They have redundant mainlines to Macon, so using the secondary one for passenger traffic is a positive revenue opportunity for them. The reason this particular line has gotten so much attention is precisely because it is feasible; not for any grand transportation planning reason.
The tracks leading into the MMPT site (going to Five Points from the west), however, are CSX mainline tracks to Augusta. Amtrak runs nearby, but on NS; getting all this to line up will require some wizardry and Class I railroads are seldom easy to bring to the table.
I actually think you are not far off on your assessment of the MMPT, and in general the MMPT is one of the least exciting things on the horizon for me. We're building a massive terminal without anything to connect with it.
My preference would be to nix the MMPT for the time being and instead focus on the Lovejoy rail line. Don't bother bringing it to downtown on the busy, congested CSX/NS shared rail line that parallels MARTA. We should just have the commuter rail line terminate in East Point, and build a station to connect with MARTA. Most people who ride the Lovejoy train will need to ride MARTA to another stop anyways; why not avoid building miles of redundant infrastructure and let them get on MARTA at the earliest possible point?
Years down the road, when the MMPT is built and commuter rail has expanded, we can consider extending the rail line to downtown. But for now it's just a needless luxury.
Also I question the positive impact train stations have on neighborhoods. Most train station areas I've been to around the world are a bit sketch. Even in cities like Oslo.