Great news for Mill, and happy to see the variety of all the places described, so it isn't just a string of bars. Would love to see more passionate entrepreneurs like this for downtown.
Quote:
Originally Posted by phxSUNSfan
Awesome, I voted for the C-shaped route as well. The possibility of extending the line to N. Mesa (Wrigleyville West) is very important. One thing I would point out is that the streetcar would not cannibalize LRT ridership because they do serve different purposes and areas. The streetcar is, of course, a more localized service and would benefit students on Apache wanting to get to Mill Ave and the Stadium (if the C-Shaped route gets built).
It would also benefit future and current residents and workers along Rio Salado who want to get to Mill quicker than walking would allow. The light rail is built to move faster over longer distances. The systems are supplemental; for instance, many living along Apache would likely take the streetcar to the nearest light rail station to get to Phoenix or to Mesa.
|
My concern isn't only cannibalization, but just being unnecessary. This students along Apache are making it to Mill ahd the stadium already- if it isn't by walking to light rail (typically, within about a mile), it's by walking, bus or bike. These residents already have quite a few options before resorting to a car; if this was just one area served, that would he totally fine. But, we are only getting such a small piece for this first stop that I think the focus should be elsewhere- gaining access to residents from areas without as many transit options currently, reaching attractions or amenities not already easily reached by any means but car, etc.
I totally agree that it should be supplemental. But, what about this line would make a resident in Mesa or near 19th avenue take the light rail when they wouldn't have otherwise? The route is hitting the exact same destinations: Mill Ave, ASU, SDS. The only benefit, as I mentioned, is easing their walk to the southern end of downtown.
Meanwhile, grabbing the part of the line that runs along Apache and using it to extend Rio further would allow the system to be truly supplemental. Terminating at Gammage (which I think is one important new stop; people aren't likely to light rail and walk in theatre clothing) still make it walkable to Apache residents if they feel it is more convenient than walking to light rail.
But, we would now give it purpose by reaching residents to the north way beyond light rail, commercial districts (once you get to Packard on Rio, I think you'd starting gaining workers who wouldn't walk that distance from 3rd/Mill), huge future mixed use residential and commercial development (SouthBank and Stadium District) and entertainment (Tempe Marketplace)... All of these places are currently hugely auto-centric, and the future developments won't be truly urban as they demand massive amounts of parking due to the lack of nearby transit.