Quote:
Originally Posted by Dillweed
The only place that happens is in Quebec.
|
The following provinces receive more back in federal spending than have collected from them (in order of most to least):
- Quebec
- Manitoba
- Nova Scotia
- New Brunswick
- PEI
- Ontario
However, this isn't an all-or-nothing thing. It's not like BC, AB, SK, and NFLD give 100% and receive 0%. All provinces get funding back, it's that some get 5% less than they put in, or 5% more, etc. These patterns also shift over time. For instance, Alberta used to be a big receiver of funding, but in the last 5 decades has been a giver. Saskatchewan was a have-not, until about 15 years ago. Ontario has gone back and forth, recently.
The whole point is to even out funding so that everyone in Canada receives roughly the same level of service, which helps keeps the country together. It's not any different than how, in an average city or RM/county, some people pay more in property taxes than a person a few streets over, but then that other person's street gets a pothole replaced earlier than yours. It's just a part of living in an organized society. Money goes into a pot, and then gets spent as-needed in the fairest way possible.
People in the west like to point out the "unfair" spending in Quebec or elsewhere, but it happens here, too. When the major federal P3 projects were being cancelled/slowed down in Trudeau's first term, Regina was able to keep funding due to Ralph Goodale's lobbying within the government. I'm sure people in some parts of the country didn't like that. But that sort of thing happens all the time, and in general, it happens quite evenly. It's just that you don't really think about the extra money your area gets for things like stadiums, public transit, swimming pools, etc, but you will more-often hear rage-bait Facebook posts about Quebec, Toronto, etc.