Quote:
Originally Posted by the urban politician
^ As a whole, Lansing/E. Lansing trails far behind Ann Arbor in how people perceive it. Growing up in Michigan, Ann Arbor was always seen as "cool, hip, trendy, artsy" while L/EL was viewed indifferently as merely the capital. Of course, the difference in ranking between U Mich and MSU plays a great role in this, but in part it also has to do with the designs of these respective towns/campuses.
MSU is an absolute goliath, but it's a separate entity from the town and everything seems so widely disconnected. U of M, on the other hand, seems to have a mostly cohesive campus that is more pedestrian-friendly and neatly ties right into the heart of Ann Arbor. Both the campus and the city (Ann Arbor) mutually benefit from this relationship.
So the more Lansing can to do make itself pedestrian friendly, urban, and tie into MSU, the better, imo.
|
As someone who attended both schools, I'm well aware of the points you make. But there are definitely things about A2 that I can't stand, most of which have to do with the pretentiousness of how great they think their city is. It's a nice little town, but I definitely did not enjoy being stuck up other students' asses whenever you're downtown. Yes, it does great things to the economy and retail/restaurant scene, but there are definitely disadvantages.
I am a big critic of Lansing/East Lansing, especially that the university was not integrated more into the city (though I do enjoy its park like setting). But I do believe that it would not take very much to make Lansing AT LEAST as desirable as Ann Arbor, if not better (in my opinion).
I think we have a more diverse economy than Ann Arbor due to State Gov't (and all of its support systems), automobile manufacturing, and multiple insurance companies. But currently many of the boomers that work in these industries are still stuck in the mindset that cities are dangerous, so they live out in the burbs. Most of the young people I know who have decent paying jobs are choosing to stay in the city. This will hopefully go a long way to revitalizing the two main downtowns and the Michigan Avenue corridor (I already see it happening at a quickening pace).
If we get the proposed transit line down Michigan (either bus rapid transit or street car), I believe a lot of the gaps in Michigan Ave will start filling in with mixed use residential, and I'm hoping some of those will hold students who are disenchanted with the student filing cabinets out in Bath Township.
Yes, it sucks that the campus is not integrated better into the city, but students have to live somewhere, and spend money, and buy groceries, and entertain themselves. I'm hoping that's how we work through the disadvantages of a large suburban style campus.
As a side note, I really enjoyed being on MSU's campus far more than U of M's, and I'm a huge fan of dense urbanism. I just felt like it was a serene place to learn, and there are so many gorgeous park-like hideaways that I felt like I was being spoiled every day. But I guess that's just personal preference.
As for art and music: yes, Lansing is way behind, and I feel like this is another area that needs to be built up to keep people around.