Quote:
Originally Posted by jollyburger
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by dreambrother808
I don’t think we want to follow the lead of a nation where such decisions are based on litigation-happy dysfunction.
|
I was just going to say, that litigation and liability issues would normally see the same case here as well whereby broken down escalators are closed off from public usage (and to be fair, some cases even in Vancouver they close them off immediately they break down until they get repaired), but you're right in noting and observing that Canadians are generally not as sue-happy as our southern cousins.
It's not just the tripping risk (people trip on regular stairs as well, and you won't have a case to sue anyone in situation like that. Besides which, most people aren't aware of the height difference in any case, to make an actual case out of it) that's the big concern.
There have been cases where people are using (read: walking up) a broken escalator and the emergency lock on the escalator fails leading to it rolling backwards along with subsequent injuries and some escalator companies actually have it in their contracts that the user firm has to close them off when they break down before the maintenance crew work on it, otherwise risk bearing all the cost of any litigation in a situation like that.
So that Seattle Transit case is not unusual and it wouldn't surprise me to learn that Translink themselves are required to do the same by their own escalator contractors.
You definitely see them closed off at (most) Skytrain stations when they break down.
At places where the building is owned by someone else (like Pacific Center at the Skytrain entrances, for example) it might get a but murky who's responsibility it is (and who therefore, would bear any liability risk.)
Also, places where you might observe them not being closed off for public use during a breakdown are more often than not places where there isn't a nearby alternative (like stairs) to use to get up and down and therefore even the broken escalator is still the default means of moving up and down.
It might explain why they were forced to build that (originally temporary, but now seemingly permanent) stair at Pacific Center shown above, because the alternative was forcing people to walk an entire block, practically, to get to the nearest stair.