Quote:
Originally Posted by city guy
excuse me fellow forum-ers...i feel I have to weigh-in here
the new safeway is a piece of crap
it contains every bland cliche of architectural ideas generated in the last 15 years and manages to combine them into an insipid collection to disjointed elements:
it has the rusticated, painted concrete treatment which typifies of most of the downtown south highrises, and scotiabank theatre, it has the arching corner element introduced by save on foods on the island many years ago, and its completely aggressive on that corner
the tilting windows, midblock, allow only one view from the sidewalk, that of the ugliest flourescent light fixtures spec'd in recent years in the downtown penninsula...a whole bank of them...and, to boot, cast against a colour which most mothers would rush their babies to the hospital with, if witnessed on anyones skin
urbanistically it is a squat and relentless insult to 3/4 of a block of the downtown...the architects and planners should be ashamed of coopting so much space with such a lack of grace
the photos posted look much better than the actual building...go take a look for yourselves, and go at night so that you can witness the worst example of a commercial lighting strategy I have seen in a long time
|
I'll go to bat for Safeway (having seen it only from the pictures) and say a few things:
the 'tilting windows, midblock' are designed to allow diffuse sunlight without blinding the customer. You'll notice that this Safeway faces morning sun; the new Urban Fare, for example, faces west and is blocked from evening sun by Carmana plaza, and so they can do full glass.
Those horrible flourescent lights are actually (at least, my guess would be from the picture) direct/indirect lighting, which is about the nicest kind of fluoro you can have for people inside the building.
The 'rusticated, painted concrete' is found on so many buildings in Vancouver for several reasons; it typifies west coast minimalism (no carpet/paint coating means longevity, simplicity, and exposed elements); it wears well; and you're not going to have to pull that purple shag concrete in 10 years when it looks tacky instead of trendy.
All in all, from the pictures, I'd say it's a good update of what was a piss-poor Safeway location.