Which of the big 3 cities is the most conservative: NYC, LA or Chicago?

[Sun Belt]

Originally Posted by Docere

% of NH whites with college degrees (city proper): 58% in L.A., 59% in NYC, 63% in Chicago

Man Alive, those New Hampshire Whites sure are makin' moves. Good for them.

[galleyfox]

Originally Posted by Handro

Odd, I would think that much more of the west than the midwest. Seattle, San Francisco, Portland, Denver, etc. have been changing so rapidly over the past 50 years, especially over the past 20, that they are basically new places. Other than the usual suspects (Detroit and maybe Cleveland) in the Midwest, which cities have had as pronounced a change as those cities? I'm not sure I've ever heard the midwest described by outsiders as "changing too much"...

'Bodenlosigkeit' has a very different meaning than change. It's a state of mind -- of being groundless, unattached. Existing in a state of exile or willful identity-loss. Many people in Europe get the strong impression that the Midwest is a region that cannot build a regional identity, which is the antithesis of Europe and unsettles them deeply. It is not a sentiment they experience in the West at all.


This article is probably closest to describing it:

Cayton blames this lack of “regional consciousness” in part on geography: “Regional identity—the creation of an imagined community—requires a strong sense of isolation. And the Midwest is not, strictly speaking, isolated. It is in the middle.” More important, however, is the intensity of local attachment: “But it is less regional rootlessness than local rootedness that makes the construction of a regional identity so difficult in the Midwest.… Localism, this pride in family, town, and state, leaves little room for interest in a coherent regional identity. In general, Midwesterners want to be left alone in worlds of their own making.”17

https://hedgehogreview.com/issues/th...n-of-normality

So a Midwesterner not wanting to identify their home city with the Midwest but rather "The North" or "The Great Lakes" is quintessential Midwest.


(Though I think you're underestimating the change that has happened in the Midwest, and overestimating the West. The California that my great-grandfather and grandfather grew up in was full of risky ventures, STEM workers and flophouses, and just generally like today.)

[Handro]

Originally Posted by galleyfox

'Bodenlosigkeit' has a very different meaning than change. It's a state of mind -- of being groundless, unattached. Existing in a state of exile or willful identity-loss. Many people in Europe get the strong impression that the Midwest is a region that cannot build a regional identity, which is the antithesis of Europe and unsettles them deeply. It is not a sentiment they experience in the West at all.


This article is probably closest to describing it:

Cayton blames this lack of “regional consciousness” in part on geography: “Regional identity—the creation of an imagined community—requires a strong sense of isolation. And the Midwest is not, strictly speaking, isolated. It is in the middle.” More important, however, is the intensity of local attachment: “But it is less regional rootlessness than local rootedness that makes the construction of a regional identity so difficult in the Midwest.… Localism, this pride in family, town, and state, leaves little room for interest in a coherent regional identity. In general, Midwesterners want to be left alone in worlds of their own making.”17

https://hedgehogreview.com/issues/th...n-of-normality

So a Midwesterner not wanting to identify their home city with the Midwest but rather "The North" or "The Great Lakes" is quintessential Midwest.


(Though I think you're underestimating the change that has happened in the Midwest, and overestimating the West. The California that my great-grandfather and grandfather grew up in was full of risky ventures, STEM workers and flophouses, and just generally like today.)

The Midwest is massive and covers some very different sub-regions--the history of Detroit is vastly different from Omaha--more so than, say, Seattle and Denver. Or Boston and New York. So perhaps traveling between these giant regions gives a sense of "Bodenlosigkeit" as you describe it. But I also am not sure where these Europeans you're talking about come from that they think "The Midwest" should have an identity, since "The Midwest" would be pretty arbitrary to anyone outside the United States (hell, even on this forum of geography nerds, people can't come to a real agreement on what places make up the Midwest!)

And anecdotally, my Italian family and their friends love the Midwest. They are in awe of the cornfields, barns, small leafy towns that in their minds define "Americana". Sure, New York is New York, LA is of the movies, and Las Vegas is an adult playground that could only exist in the US, but they love visiting us here and always ask to take (the most seemingly boring) day trips to experience the vast flatness around Chicago.

[Cory]

Originally Posted by Docere

% of NH whites with college degrees (city proper): 58% in L.A., 59% in NYC, 63% in Chicago

Why are the stats just for that group relevant? Asking for a friend.

[Kenmore]

easily chicago

[iheartthed]

Originally Posted by galleyfox

So a Midwesterner not wanting to identify their home city with the Midwest but rather "The North" or "The Great Lakes" is quintessential Midwest.

Wait, what? lol. Does this also apply to a place like Maryland? Because Maryland was South and now it's North, in a kind of not-so-southern, not-so-northern purgatory. Virginia is also creeping into that category. And West Virginia went from being northern to being southern.

[CaliNative]

Originally Posted by iheartthed

Wait, what? lol. Does this also apply to a place like Maryland? Because Maryland was South and now it's North, in a kind of not-so-southern, not-so-northern purgatory. Virginia is also creeping into that category. And West Virginia went from being northern to being southern.

Southern Ohio, especially the southeast hilly part, has a very southern feeling. Looks like W. Virginia and the people talk like W. Virginians. A lot of them came from there. southern Indiana and far south Illinois also have a southern vibe.