Quote:
Originally Posted by Xing
This may be an unpopular opinion, but I believe all the construction in Clayton takes away from the demand to build downtown. There is such a culture of destroying old, and building new in St. Louis, even when there is so much that can be revitalized, it’s mind numbing. It’s like, they even built a new downtown. Even with that though, downtown remains resilient. Imagine how much more could go on without Clayton sucking all the development away.
|
I think that's the prevailing opinion actually, at least regarding the state of things now. Though Clayton probably absorbed some of the 80s, 90s, 00s corporate flight that otherwise would have ended up farther out in the suburbs. I do like that Clayton, U City, and Wash U create a walkable urban bookend on the West side Forest Park. If the city can start adding appreciable population again, the stretch from DT to Clayton will densify quickly—it's already happening to some extent with development picking up in DT West and Midtown, and steady growth in the CWE.
DT's main problem is that it's disconnected from the rest of the city. We badly need contiguous, walkable, residential infill between the CBD and points North and West. Connectivity to the South will likely remain a problem as long as the rail yards are there. And then there's East St. Louis... Man, I wish Alton were directly across the river from DT. That would be amazing.
Regarding the culture of destruction, it's gotten a whole lot better on the South Side and in the Central Corridor. Even some Near North Side neighborhoods (e.g. West End, Academy) are starting to see $400K–$500K rehabs (thanks largely to Wash U's efforts). Unfortunately, rehabs of historic brick buildings cost a shit-load of money and most of the North Side market just won't support that yet.
Oh, arson and vagrants burning down vacant buildings continue to be a HUGE problem as well. We recently lost another historic North Side church (1) AND another historic Near North Side warehouse (2) AND a substantial historic North Side corner building that had just received a permit for rehab before suspiciously burning down (3). I'm sure that's not all. Is there another city in the US (or the world for that matter) that loses so many buildings to arson?
(1)
(2)
(3)