Quote:
Originally Posted by peanut gallery
Thanks for that, Jerry. You're right, the lighter panels are a different color than what they depicted, but I personally like it. If I recall correctly, you weren't a big fan of the original rendering either so maybe this one just isn't your cup of tea. I haven't seen it in person yet either. But going by the photos, I think it looks good. Hopefully, it will grow on you a little bit.
|
I think this building looks worse than 1450 Franklin. Sorry not sorry but it's the worst looking building I've seen go up in such a long time. I always liked the bland original (taller I believe) design for this building better, as bland as it was. This was a disaster in the rendering and turned out even worse in reality. Architects clearly had a very limited budget and didn't know how to turn something out with it. After this, I'd say if the budget's limited, just play it safe and go boring. These precast panels are the WORST. You couldn't pay me a million dollars to live there - I'd vomit every time I walked in and out the front door. Ewwwww (put me in the MUCH better looking affordable housing across the street!)
As for 1450 Franklin - this project continues to baffle the mind. First was their rinky dink looking system for putting up the steel frame - a very [frail?] looking steel frame. There's that whole concrete contraption for retail below. Looks like a bunker. Then now there's this weird piecemeal and slow process of putting up what looks like an advanced version of drywall on the exterior. The thing working for them is the fact that they went with a standard "big 3" contractor in this city, and it wasn't some no-name. But still, based on what I've seen during construction, you couldn't pay me a billion dollars to live there. With my luck, we'd see a 7.5 mag quake the day after I finished moving in, and the building's "test-pilot" engineering would fail and the whole thing would collapse with me and 100-200+ other people in it. Just doesn't seem like it meets standards, but at 13 stories and high visibility on the Franklin corridor, there's no way in hell this extremely bureaucratic city didn't run 5,000 inspections on it and intensely review the permitted plans.
RE: the Rockwell - yea that glass looks funky, wasn't what I was necessarily expecting. I live nearby so will continue to monitor.
RE: 1545 Pine - yes, this building looks good, but it will be hulking. If there were any complaints about massing, I would have actually understood where they were coming from because this building is going to be bigger in reality than it looks in the renderings. Also, the neighborhood rallied behind keeping the facades of those one story buildings on Pine. The renderings were updated at one point. I personally thought that was stupid - these aren't significant buildings and it will be no architectural loss to see them go. But I don't see them incorporated into the latest renderings found on Socketsite - were these architectural incorporations stricken? I would be happy if so. But I am excited it's moving forward - it is a good looking rendering and the kind of rendering that doesn't seem like it would be misleading. So I think that's about what we can expect, and I say let's get the dirt moving soon!