Quote:
Originally Posted by yveseluj
It's a terrible analogy, demonstrably untrue, and Québecers don't see themselves as superior.
Glad to see Québec bashing knows no bounds. /s
|
Yeah people in Quebec don't view themselves as superior. They may think some of the ways they do things are better (as each province and culture feels, and is often correct about), but as a people they don't feel they are better.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stormer
I think we are talking about their self perception of cultural superiority, which is hard to refute.
As far as Quebec bashing, I am pretty sure it is 3rd only to hockey and CFL as the favourite sport in Saskatchewan, but only because they make it so easy. 
|
I don't think they believe their culture is superior at all. Do you have any actual examples to support your claim? Preferably backed by sources or data.
Quebec bashing is popular here because Saskatchewan is a pretty rural and xenophobic place that tends to view other places negatively. Anything different or "fancy" is looked down upon. Heck, even the "big" cities of Regina and Saskatoon are made fun of in many small towns. Small minds fear bigger things or different things, and xenophobia and fear of the "other" results.
Quote:
Originally Posted by StealthGirl
This is what I meant. In 2006, Quebec was recognized in parliament as a nation within Canada; the Bloc wanted to be recognized as a nation without the distinction "in Canada". The Bloc was pushing for this as a way to weaken the federal Liberals in Canada. But Bloc aside, there are still shades of this showing up in discussions with regards to Quebec now. It is a cultural perception. I wasn't meaning it as a bash, but as something real. Even this week, Trudeau stated Quebec is a nation.
http://montrealgazette.com/news/local-news/yes-quebec-is-a-nation-justin-trudeau-says
|
Quebec was recognized as a nation because culturally they are a distinct nation, with their own language, laws (civic compared to common law) and values. The term nation in this context is referring to culture, not to the modern definition of nation-state. People often get that confused. The entire thing was a move by the federal Conservatives to shore up support in Quebec and to further weaken the Liberals, but it was still contextually accurate.
Among historians and other experts you won't find much disagreement that Quebec is indeed a distinct cultural nation within Canada and North America. All provinces and regions of Canada and the US are different than each other to some extent, but Quebec is so far off the charts in the differences that they really are unique. I would argue that Quebec is more different from Ontario or Saskatchewan than either of those two are from the USA.