Quote:
Originally Posted by Keith P.
Quite an interesting post, Saul, after the spirited defense of the outdated 737 you made to me here last year. I was highlighting the awful experience of flying trans-oceanic on the MAX, and you tried to pooh-pooh that. Now those issues are finally leading to changes thanks to AC actually listening to customers. Refreshing. Good on AC for finally doing the right thing.
|
Was wondering when you'd chime in, Keith.
You clearly misunderstand what’s happening here. The notion that ”those issues are finally leading to changes thanks to AC actually listening to customers” is simply wrong. This is patently
not a case of AC replacing the 737 MAX on transoceanic routes because of any perceived deficiency or passenger dissatisfaction. It’s about standardizing the Rouge fleet on a single aircraft type with greater range and fuel efficiency and lower operating and maintenance costs than the three older-generation Airbus types it currently operates. Those are huge considerations in the highly competitive budget vacation market. And with Rouge, they’ll still be flying long transoceanic routes.
The move to the A321XLR in the mainline AC fleet is happening (as its name suggests) because of its range - a whopping 1200 nautical miles/2200 km greater than the MAX 8, which opens up a lot of new routes previously accessible only to much larger wide-body aircraft (777/787/A330). That it apparently also offers greater comfort in business class than the MAX 8 is simply a bonus.
I maintain everything I said about the 737 MAX last time around. By any objective standard, passenger comfort in economy class in the MAX 8 is not materially different from any of its competitors. If it were, airlines wouldn’t continue to buy them in large numbers. Margins in the notoriously cutthroat industry are razor-thin. Nobody can afford to operate a less competitive airplane. Did you miss the fact that WestJet just recently upped its MAX 10 order by an additional
60 - with options on another 25?
My post above was about business class creature comforts. Folks I know who travel the YHZ-LHR route often and were used to flying business class on 767s say it was much superior to the 737 experience. Personally, I wouldn't know. But I do know that in the economy-class cabin there’s no real difference. For that matter, my worst-ever transatlantic flight by far wasn’t on a 737, it was on the much larger 767, and that was all down to seat pitch.