Quote:
Originally Posted by Chronamut
It does when the planning dept is the one approving it and it directly affects THEIR building lol.. city nimbyism hahaha..
if i had to guess it probably will be smaller on the corner and step up to higher the farther back it goes into the plot. So it might still be tall but it won't be directly fronting the king william side street like a giant slab like the lister block does, but obv. much higher.
That of course assumes that plot will EVER get developed.. I actually liked the look of the buildings that were originally on that plot - I felt they were more harmonious with that strip. Tall for the sake of tall is never a good solution - it should fit with everything around it.
|
This is what I would expect. The owners of the lot know what they have, and know what they can-and will- do with it. 30 stories is a given for any downtown lot in my books at this point, given that we canât go taller in some places to make others shorter elsewhere. That said, setbacks are more than called for on the lot in question, and not just to bring visual attention to King William, but also to respect Jamesâ street wall. The question I always ask is if the city actually has the competence to ensure that the eventual development considers these things. There are too many instances already where there is no conventional urban design wisdom considered. While itâs created an âorganicâ charm that exemplifies the raw market interest in the Hammer rather than some artificially induced âgrowthâ (Yknow those small districts in rust belt cities that end as quick as they start) , sometimes we need that attention to detail, and the city hasnât provided it thus far. Sometimes it feels like it would literally kill us (or a project, I suppose) to make such small asks.
Still, developers have shown before that the more valuable their lot, the more theyâll put into bells and whistles to make it nice. This isnât the edge of downtown, this is the part of the core thatâs been desirable since before I was born AFAIK. I expect a quality brick treatment (or something of similar quality) on the podium at a minimum for anything proposed on James for the foreseeable future. In short, a developer couldnât get away with the Vranich (âikeaâ) treatment!