Quote:
Originally Posted by hipster duck
It's a very Western conceit to believe that the world is going to end one generation from now. Other cultures have a more cavalier attitude about climate change, and I'm wondering if they're not wrong. People from cultures that have experienced trauma more recently also aren't that afraid to hit the reset button. It's actually kind of liberating.
|
It is a difficult conversation but you always have to keep these things in perspective. Covid was very similar with the risks not registering in much of the world while we pulled out all the stops here, probably with only marginal impact in the end for a lot of the policies.
I think there is something you might call the "clockwork society fallacy" related to "scientism", which is that you can do a bit of analysis and then mechanistically project out the consequences of that but it's much harder to say what else might change in the future or how people will react. As an example, lots of people manage to survive in Arizona but there are projections about huge numbers of people dying farther north due to heat waves. That is just an issue we have to contemplate and respond to. By and large I think that given the way the world is if we have good institutions and politics we will (massively) outgrow any global warming problems.
If you want to complain about stratas, we had a huge heatwave that killed hundreds of people last year here and they still fight against AC unit installation. That is not a climate change issue, that's a boring small time social issue.
BTW a second fallacy is that economic growth is zero sum in some way (getting physical stuff, environmental impact; there are different flavours) and so we have to either have more negative environmental impact to have a better standard of living. This is not true at all, and in the future we may have much larger energy budgets with a lower impact. The environment overall was more degraded in a lot of places centuries in the past than it is today, due to deforestation and pollution. CO2 is a milder problem than 1600's deforestation or Victorian-era pea soup coal fog, although it is global in scope.