Quote:
Originally Posted by Doady
Oakville and Markham are the two Toronto suburbs that are heavily influenced by New Urbanism and maybe you can see that in these pictures, and from quick glance at satellite image. The mayor of Ajax is a planner so maybe it has some more thoughtful design than usual as well (e.g. a continuous public waterfront).
Probably the main thing holding Oakville back is the lack of integrated local transit network. Oakville Transit is just too small. Halton and Peel (minus Caledon) should have been one region from the beginning, and with Halton-Peel Transit we could have had one "GTA West" transit system. The ridership of the Dundas Street corridor is already almost on par with Hurontario-Main, but if the service from Oakville to Mississauga to Etobicoke was integrated, they probably would be building Dundas LRT right now, not just Hurontario LRT.
I know I will be labelled as a "conspiracy theorist" for saying this, but it's just just another example how political divisions are holding the Toronto area back. You can see also the Steeles situation along the Toronto and York boundary as well, how it is killing transit ridership in York and isolating people who live near the boundary.
|
What's the "Steeles situation"?
Oakville is pretty affluent and low density compared to Mississauga, which I think limits transit demand, aside from the demand for commuter service into Downtown Toronto. The newer developments are more mixed income and denser though, so I think that will change over the coming decades. Trafalgar and Dundas can probably support pretty frequent bus service soon, maybe even BRT, and maybe eventually other corridors like Upper Middle, Third Line, Speers, Lakeshore and Dorval-West Oak Trails can support relative frequent transit too.
Although I agree Oakville and Markham are most heavily influenced by new urbanism, the other suburbs still have a lot of similarities. The development densities are basically the same in most new suburban areas regardless of municipality, and that's reflected in a lot of other things like distance to transit, schools and other amenities. Laneways to limit garages/driveways along more prominent streets, or for narrow lot homes (ex townhouses) are also common in a lot of Toronto suburbs. Even the live-work units can be found outside Markham/Oakville, most notably in Milton, but also Brampton, Burlington and Caledon.