![]() |
In other collegiate news -
Quote:
|
[QUOTE=deja vu;10088226]A mishmash of things today, including several aerial views that I have been saving up, from some of our local, talented drone photographers -
City skyline, from about a month back, with the changing leaves - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/4ih30...mkrdbc6y&raw=1 Source: Facebook | William Dolak Another angle, with a closeup on the new(ish) 180 E Water St. / Catalyst Development - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/xbg3i...q4og0ukg&raw=1 Source: Facebook | William Dolak A late summer aerial photo from near Kalamazoo / Battle Creek International Airport, right beneath the final approach vector for runway 35. This is a great shot that really exemplifies the natural "valley" topography of the city - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/pxjkm...k6ol7qnl&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Caleb Stauffer (Stauffer Aerial) These next three are all aerial views concentrated on the four blocks of Arcadia West, which are being cleared & vacated for the future event center. The last few of the old buildings on these blocks are now cleared - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/2jgw1...0numa4wm&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Caleb Stauffer (Stauffer Aerial) A unique, low-altitude fish-eye rendering of an empty downtown Kalamazoo on Thanksgiving day - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/3s1om...xy39if2v&raw=1 Source: Facebook | William Dolak It’s great to see Kalamazoo getting a event center it’ll help open the doors to even more opportunities with its already remarkable run of downtown development over the past decade or so. Great set I picked out a few favorites. Downtown has come a long way from my school days when we’d pack up for the weekend and decide to hit up wastern for a spot of drinking. The difference in Western’s campus is night and day from what I’ve seen it was a bit bleak with the 60’s-70’s era student housing and student center especially if your walking hungover for some T-Bell in the am. Downtown improved in ever way shape and form perhaps there was more to it 12-14 years ago but I didn’t interact with it like I did would in Ann Arbor though that’s a bit unfair. The Kalamazoo promise seems to be one of the unhearled success stories of our time. Perhaps because it involves free education. The caveat if I remember being a district graduate and it’s only up through the junior college level (though with a nice easy transfer potential) it’s disappointing that more cities haven’t taken up the idea. Kalamazoo has had a remarkable turnaround and it’s kept right on going. West Michigan’s strong economy certainly hasn’t hurt but Battle Creek was in a similar position to Kzoo a back in the day. It’s not apples to apples each city has its strong and weak points but Kalamazoo has been able to use its strength in education as a springboard and tapped into the strong regional economy. BC is a bit further east though there are some nice lakes in the forest north of 94 between the two cities it’s not within as easy reach of Lake Michigan though it’s less snowy. Kzoo doesn’t have a major corporate HQ like BC does in Kellogg’s although the opportunities for the white collar jobs aren’t plentiful like the cereal production jobs were. BC seems to be making some strides towards improving its rather stagnant position the Marshall battery plant and the HSR line continuing on from Detroit to Toronto both offer some opportunities. I think there’s a good tale of two cities tale to be examined what Kzoo has done and succeeded at what BC has done to improve its downtown and didn’t succeed the pedestrian street in the downtown shopping district comes to mind. A pedestrian street isn’t necessarily a bad idea perhaps bad timing and execution can be partially blamed. Battle Creek has an opportunity to capitalize on its riverwalk and plenty of parking to redevelop or expand green space across from downtown. Getting some more mixed use redevelopments in its quite nice downtown for a city it’s size is another opportunity. Love the fisheye aerial. |
I'm among those who click on this thread, when I see it updated. I like Michigan cities and I like to see what the peer cities of the city I post on are doing. Which everyone should do.
The similar-sized city I post on also offers some type of free college to local high school graduates up to the junior college level and they can transfer to a four-year college. They are required to stay in the city for two years after getting that degree or certification. I think Kalamazoo started that movement, which I think one or more (not sure how many?) states have tried... yes, at the statewide level! There was an effort to make it national at one time. |
Quote:
I don't have as far back of a reference point as it sounds like you do for Kalamazoo. I think my first time visiting here was 2012. We moved here in 2015. So I can really only (personally) recall back about ten years, and it wasn't until we moved here that I began to really understand the urban context (and form my own opinions about it). In that 8-year time span, I'd say that the city has definitely improved in most (but not all) categories of measurement. I think the biggest challenges still seem to be homelessness, higher-than-average violent crime rates, higher-than-average poverty rates, and a shortage of affordable housing options. No doubt those issues are all somewhat intertwined. I wish Kalamazoo hadn't lost as much downtown building stock as it did in the back half of the 20th century - if more of the historic commercial (and even lighter industrial) buildings could have withstood the test of time for a few more decades, we would have that many more opportunities for repurposing structures into badly-needed housing. Housing development - especially any with a public funding component - moves at a glacial pace around here. Take the modular tiny home proposal that came to light in the dark, early days of the pandemic, - the city has yet to even determine an acceptable chunk of property to park them on (they've been debating that topic off-and-o for the greater part of 3 years now). As for the downtown not having a major corporate HQ like Battle Creek does, I've thought about this often, and fantasized about what the city would look like if Upjohn (now Pfizer) hadn't fled downtown to the open pastures of Portage, starting in the 1940's. And for that matter, why doesn't Stryker, a fortune 500 company, will all of its billions, have a downtown presence? Because they also opted for building sprawly-type campuses in the cheap, open fields of Portage with their friendly corporate tax structure. Don't get me wrong - Kalamazoo still benefits vastly from having Stryker and Pfizer in its backyard. There's hardly a project in the city that doesn't have an Upjohn or a Stryker-related family name tied-to it. But, if one or both of those entities had a major presence downtown today, can you imagine...? This fantasy usually then leads me to wish that Portage had never incorporated as a city. Once it did, the fate of Kalamazoo proper's manufacturing future was pretty much sealed. Instead, as it is, Kalamazoo City's two largest employers? Bronson Healthcare (~9,000) and Western Michigan University (~ 6,000). And guess what? They are both non-profit / tax-exempt entities with massive footprints within the city proper. Now obviously, these contribute to the economy in their own way, with many high-paying jobs, education, etc. But it's not the same as a corporation pumping guaranteed tax dollars into city coffers each year. Kalamazoo is a bit of the inverse of many cities, wherein more people live in the city proper, but they commute out to the suburbs for daily work. Sometimes I think it would be great if Kalamazoo, Portage, and the remaining, eviscerated chunks of Kalamazoo Township (where I reside, btw) all just coalesced into one unified municipality. It would have a population of roughly 150,000 - which would put it in the top-five largest in Michigan. They could share public infrastructure, everyone could vote on things that affect them every day, there could be one unified public safety department, one unified school district, etc. etc. Where I live, I'm surrounded on 3 sides by the city limits. I live three minutes from downtown where I work. And yet, I can't vote for the Mayor. The main argument against this is that taxes would go up. That argument made sense like 60 years ago. But not so much nowadays. For the average homeowner, I suspect that taxes would only increase slightly, and the benefits would be vast. Battle Creek and Kalamazoo also both have huge opportunities to capitalize on their riverfronts. I'd give both about an F+ grade in this regard. I think most casual visitors to Kalamazoo probably don't even realize that there is a prominent river located a few minutes' walk from the downtown. I know industrialization and pollution have played a huge role in both cities turning their backs on the river. But a lot of that pollution has been mitigated now, so why is development (even of parks and walking trails) still so stymied? The Upjohn Company, Building 41, under-construction in Portage, 1941 (below). To me, this symbolizes the beginning of the end of large-scale manufacturing within the Kalamazoo city proper. BTW, if you aren't familiar with the story of Portage's incorporation as a city, check it out - it is an interesting one. Basically, a race against the clock between Portage Township (to incorporate), and the City of Kalamazoo (to annex it), in a bid for the Upjohn money. Spoiler alert: Portage won that race. https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/mvitk...8h1q4x86&raw=1 Source: upjohn.net |
Quote:
Yes, I'm pretty sure Kalamazoo lays claim to being the first entity to try a system like The Promise. A state or nationwide system sounds amazing... one can dream. |
Portage -
I've not been keeping close tabs on Kalamazoo's ever-suburbanizing neighbor to the south. It's usually less-interesting development to me, and it's just hard to celebrate sprawl. Because of that attitude, I missed some things that will bring a little more density to the city. While updating the project rundown in the opening post of this thread, I noticed two substantive residential projects planned for Portage. The first is StoryPoint South, a 3-story, 177,000 SF / 172-unit senior housing development at 8150 Creekside Drive. According to MLive, this was expected to break ground last May, so I will have to swing by there to see where things are really at. The facility will have studio, one-bedroom, and two-bedroom apartments, grouped in a memory care wing, assisted living wing, enhanced living wing and 93 independent living apartments. It will compliment the existing StoryPoint Portage facility that is located at 3951 W Milham Avenue. https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/0upp4...fpgs5w1t&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/zcpha...e531gwqz&raw=2 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/yuf30...g0l3sg7b&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/2j1y4...x6mr32wb&raw=1 Source: MLive | City of Portage The second project is Kings Landing, a 95-unit apartment and townhome complex, to be located at the SE corner of Constitutional Blvd. and MLK Dr. (directly across from the new Dr. MLK Jr. Park). The proposal consists of two three-story buildings and one four-story building (which qualifies as a high-rise, by Portage standards). 82 apartment flats and 13 townhomes. Of the apartments, 33 would be one-bedroom units and 49 would be two-bedroom units. The project was approved in late-2022 and it required a rezoning from RM-1 multifamily to planned development in one of the last remaining developable plats of land from the original Romence and Snow family farms. More info - Quote:
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/gcpef...72jma3mu&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/x73h2...jyf9rro6&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/aarrm...wb5gnl5n&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/vipsj...bc0r6b7b&raw=1 Source: MLive | Integrated Architecture | Provided By City of Portage |
There is an old church that is currently being demolished on Kalamazoo's Northside, at 1101 N Westnedge Avenue. Originally known simply as the Reformed Church, it was built in the late 1800s by a growing congregation of Dutch heritage. The reformists eventually move to the suburbs in 1981, and rebranded as Centerpoint Church around 2000. They have been thriving there ever-since, and today, they are not even aligned with the Reformed Church in America (source). The building had several tenants through the succeeding years after reformists left. Most recently, it was sold by the North Westnedge Church of Christ to the Galilee Baptist Church in 2021 (located across the street in their own building since 1971).
An aerial view, from August 2021 - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/s5s1l...rsbpsa8i&raw=1 Source: Flickr | Bill Dolak An interior view, taken March 2023 by someone. In clear disarray, but potentially still salvageable (for a high price) - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/a0ujx...jkk47o9p&raw=1 Source: Google User Content Recent demo photos - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/4qxmb...gffl9ldv&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/1yi6a...kdwm99wl&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Heritage Architectural Salvage & Supply https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/soflq...9l6fb5uj&raw=1 Source: Facebook | The Galilee Baptist Church My first reaction was disappointment and resignation that yet another historic church was coming down. I assumed it would just become a grassy lot, or parking. But, the Baptists actually have a development plan for the site. Per their website: Quote:
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/qu1oi...p0261jfr&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Clare Hollander |
WMU plans to tear down dorms, build new residence hall
https://www.mlive.com/resizer/m4ZK2q...HBES3ITGAQ.jpg Quote:
|
^ I recall years ago WMU announcing its intention to demolish all (3) of the Valley dorm complexes. Then it just went quiet. I think maybe a combination of less enrollment, along with focusing more time and capital on the south neighborhood reimagining, might have both played a part. So, this isn't a total shock, it just makes me wonder how soon until Valley 1 & Valley 2 also will be demolished. WMU is methodically erasing its sprawlier, mid-century past, in favor of denser, more-concentrated mixed-use districts that are less auto-centric. It's like its own little mini-city.
|
There's a downtown Kalamazoo placemaking workshop scheduled for tonight -
Quote:
|
Quote:
Overall, I'm excited that they are studying this, but still a bit skeptical about what will actually be implemented. The updated conceptual drawings will be posted soon for online viewing. A little more info / news coverage below- Quote:
|
New renderings for $300M downtown arena cast spotlight on Western Michigan University
https://www.mlive.com/resizer/UBhEIs...VJMYWCCZ3M.jpg Quote:
|
The Arena-area site plans show a parking ramp sitting on the site south of Arcadia Creek previously planned for high-rise residential development. I hope this prompts more dense residential further west toward the WMU campus along Michigan / Stadium Dr.
And does the 'multi-use event hall' seem kinda .... small? |
So is it *actually* happening now? Or moving in to year 23 of planning :haha:
I do hope it's built and it triggers some mixed-use development on the surrounding blocks. |
^ I'm not loving that design. It feels clunky and funky, and not in a good way. I admit it is hard (even unfair) to past judgement on it with out being involved in the planning sessions directly. I'm sure there are reasons for all of the moves portrayed in these renderings. I'm not a big fan of the giant Bronco logo, or the prevalent use of brown and gray materials. The whole thing looks very dated and chaotic. And yes, the event hall does look small to me. Overall, a lot of clashing ideas and concepts.
And it's hugely disappointing to see zero mixed-use / housing component whatsoever. There's clearly a lot to work out in this design still. Here's hoping for better, through the design process. |
A mish-mash of other updates, in no particular order -
1. The Corner Bar & Grill is being demolished. The building, located at the southwest corner of Mills & Vine, was pretty large - basically a 6,000 SF wooden shed. The bar's existence was before my time, but plenty of folks on Facebook are lamenting the lost / reminiscing about the good times had here. This photo was posted online, taken 1/19/24 - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/u81uu...du5cezuw&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Rose Norwood Here's another from 1/21/24 - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/mnog3...ck33wkze&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Justin J. Byrd I did a mini deep-dive to try and learn more about the past & future of the site. It closed more than a decade ago for day-to-day business (in October 2011), reportedly due to the tough economy at the time. It remained in some capacity as a base for The Corner Catering Company (though I'm not sure if that is still operating, as the last Facebook post was April 2020). Based on city GIS data, it reads like the main building was only 35 years old, but per this MLive article, that seems to actually just be a reference to when the bar opened, relative to the date it closed, which would be 1976. The same article says the structure itself was built in 1887. Which surprised me, because based on the 1908 Sanborn Map, it definitely looks like there was a detached residence standing on this corner at the time. So something isn't adding up. The current ownership is also curious - the taxpayer is listed as "Choose Your Home, LLC" - with an address that traces to a medical office in Oshtemo Township (3601 S 9th St #2) that is operated by a Stephen Dallas, MD. "Choose Your Home" also owns an empty lot on the opposite side of Vine. Even more curious, the owner is listed as "Atlas Housing & Development, Inc" with a physical address that points me to the Blue Dolphin restaurant, in downtown Kalamazoo (502 S Burdick St). This doesn't make much sense, because the owner and taxpayer info for the Blue Dolphin doesn't match that. In conclusion, I really have no idea what is intended long-term for this site, but based solely on the names of the involved entities, hopefully some sort of new development is taking its place. Also, sad to read that the owner - Scott Robinson - died in 2015, when he was only 48 years old (obituary). 2. The Zone 32 / Bogan Development is officially complete. Article link below, including some photos plus a teaser of more development to come - Quote:
Source: Nate Pappas | MLive 3. In potentially good news for fans of nature (I am in that camp), the owner of Drive & Shine has officially withdrawn a rezoning request for the lot at the southeast corner of Stadium and Drake - Quote:
Quote:
Source: Instagram | @wildbullkzoo 5. (technically in Parchment, but, close-enough) The announcement that the YWCA will purchase the former Advia CU HQ ish is potentially good news. If nothing else, it will activate the building more. And Advia CU is going to maintain a branch in the first floor - Quote:
Source: Ryan Boldrey | MLive 6. The city announced it plans to purchase & install two more "Portland Loos" in the near-future. Quote:
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/hm4n4...j5u2j7j4&raw=1 Source: Jessi Phillips | WMUK 7. Speaking of Arcadia Creek Festival site, the City Commission reviewed and approved the 2024 budget on January 2024. During the public comment period, residents pointed out that the city had earmarked $1.65 million for a redesign of Arcadia Creek Festival Place. It's well-known that this site needs a new life, but it was the first I read that the proposed redesign by the city would involve dividing the site roughly in half, in order to make room for a mixed-use residential building, with the remaining park half being fenced in. As you could imagine, this doesn't sit well with many (including myself). I'm all for bringing new housing downtown, but not at all in-favor of fencing off one of the last remaining spaces in the city that the unhoused can shelter in. So after the commenting period, Commissioners voted to remove the funding for Arcadia Creek Festival place, and they passed the rest of the budget unanimously. You can read more about it here - Quote:
(photo is a bit washed-out due to the window reflection and the morning sunlight) https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/h8acl...eyt7j2jn&raw=1 9. (technically in Oshtemo Township) the former Chime School (6750 Chime St) is soon to be demolished. Most recently, this housed a charter academy. I know this era / design of school is pretty "dime-a-dozen" but a part of me still cringes when something like this gets torn down. So many memories for so many former students in that building. The owners of the building reportedly really let it fall apart though (or, to put it a nicer way, couldn't afford the upkeep) - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8je08...mq0nx6k0&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/9g1ea...pnjt2bnt&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/f5s9k...4lya5kzl&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Kevin Worth 10. That small K College "addition" that I commented about, a few posts back (see Post #999) is actually part of a much larger project, intended to upgrade the entire medium-voltage infrastructure on the campus, which is 80+ years old. There's a short video about it here, posted by OAK - 11. Related, this work will lay the foundation for supporting other initiatives of the campus master plan, chief among them, the new residence hall that is planned for along W. Main. While we still don't have any renderings or details, the info on the Facilities Management page gives us a few clues -
Close to the road and at 5 stories, this will definitely impact the experience approaching / leaving downtown - ![]() ![]() Source: facilities.kzoo 12. KPL is closing the Alma Powell library branch on the northside, due to a change in security protocol by the Douglas Community Association, which owns the building that the library operates within. There could be a silver lining to this though, as long-term plans involve either moving the branch to a vacant space that would be renovated, or else building a new building entirely - Quote:
Quote:
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/fim1l...ngj1kjs2&raw=1 Source: City of Kalamazoo 15. The old neon sign on the Paris Cleaners at Crosstown Pkwy. was reportedly just removed. I can't find any info on why (is it being restored, are they closing, is it permanent? etc.). Here's an older photo of the sign (from 2011, when it was last restored) - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/n91ab...rwrldb4s&raw=1 Source: Flickr | Bill Dolak 16. Nearby, Barrio is set to open any day now (a few months later than originally anticipated). Here's a peek inside - it looks like they will have a walk-up service window opening into Haymarket Plaza, which is pretty cool - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/w3v18...mxj4l7ke&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/iox9a...rk40qkha&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/04dol...yhadex25&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/1vb50...019u2eqi&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Treystar 17. Last, the city is planning to install a bunch of new security cameras in / around the Epic Center Parking Ramp (43 to be exact). I've never felt threatened or unsafe in there; I wonder if it is more an effort to curtail actions by unhoused, including public urination. There is a strong stench in the stairwells and elevators. This could also be a prelude to some rumors that I've heard, regarding the intent to do a full Epic Center renovation - Quote:
|
Yesterday, I went and checked out the Reformed Church building that is being demolished in Kalamazoo's Northside, at 1101 N Westnedge Avenue. It is little more than a pile of debris now -
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/iuvb2...wm52ex2o&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/lr4rx...336y6gbq&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/9yrvi...jv3bxhei&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/ziua3...3iaou0sj&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/ad35w...v2ch62e3&raw=1 Fortunately, at least someone was able to salvage the old church bell - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/wa1ra...512saw24&raw=1 Source: Facebook | Tim Doorlag As one comes down, another one rises. Here is 530 S Rose, from a few days ago - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/7rop1...4p0p6ze4&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/5cn65...jsyw1t2w&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/n3fa9...dxzx989y&raw=1 |
Two new site plan reviews have been posted -
708 N Burdick St (review date: 2/21/24) - mixed-use redevelopment of an existing building to create some ground floor office space and six residential units. The existing building is one of the last remnants of a one-time commercial district (located here). 2156 Race St (review date: 2/28/24) - public park improvements, planned for Southside Park, in the Edison Neighborhood (located here). |
The City Commission took up the topic of the planned Arcadia Creek Festival Site renovation again, in a meeting of the whole, last week. City planners tried to set the record straight on what the development plans are. Apparently there was some misinformation / misinterpretation of the early design documents. The assistant city planner clarified that there was never a plan to enclose the public portion of the park with a permanent fence, and that while it is true that they want to develop the northern portion of the site into housing, the proposed layout of the remaining space will actually result in more usable space than what is there currently. Overall, this is a bit more reassuring to me -
Quote:
Source: MLive | City of Kalamazoo |
Visually from the street, there has been very little progress at 530 S Rose in about a month. Today I spotted a crew unloading boards that I guessed might be used to start setting framing for the 2nd floor, but not 100% sure about that -
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/xgqq5...fjpu90kn&raw=1 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/rwpii...gg6egk22&raw=1 In other "tiny" news, a sign popped up at the Corner of Westnedge Ave. and North St. sometime last week, for the Tiny Houses of HOPE project. So I guess this might actually happen. I still think it is a weird location for tiny homes, at such a high-traffic intersection. I snapped a quick drive-by photo as I was turning - https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/dwlw2...tofhsv4n&raw=1 |
| All times are GMT. The time now is 2:47 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.