Transit Adjacent Development


M II A II R II K

Active member
TAD or TOD? A Look at the W at Hollywood and Vine


March 31, 2010

by Damien Newton

site-head-logo-sblogla.gif


Read More: http://la.streetsblog.org/2010/03/3...t-oriented-development-at-hollywood-and-vine/

One of my favorite transportation rhetorical devices has always been the relationship between Transit Oriented Development, or TOD, and its evil brother, Transit Adjacent Development, TAD. TAD breaks all the rules that make TOD work, but because they can look similar they often get confused. Unfortunately, TAD can give TOD a bad name.

From Reconnecting America, a national non-profit that advocates for more and better TOD nationwide, explains the difference between TAD and TOD in this article in Mass Transit Magazine.

TAD is TOD gone bad, development that is adjacent to transit but breaks all the rules that make TOD work, like making public spaces the focus of building orientation and neighborhood activity; creating pedestrian-friendly street networks that directly connect local destinations; and providing a mix of housing types, densities and costs.

Other definitions of Transit Oriented Development include "restriction of automobile parking," "affordable housing elements" and "bicycle access."

Reading some of Stephen Box's criticism of Metro and the W in recent weeks, it got me to wonder. Is the W, the diamond of Metro's TOD programming, really transit oriented or merely transit adjacent? We've already seen how some of Metro's other "TOD" projects undermine themselves by having an abundance of automobile parking, even more than the state average; or desperately announce to the public their free parking. The best argument that it is truly a piece of Transit Oriented Development comes from The Source. Fred Camino writes lovingly of the beautiful work done to connect the station to the plaza in front of the W.

Beyond aesthetics, the redesign is functional, effectively creating a fantastic public space with ample seating and plenty of access to transit information. According to Metro staff involved in the redesign, much work was put into making sure the station entrance was unmistakeably visible from the street in order to adhere to the goals of TOD, and I’d say they’ve succeeded admirably. With the exception of an unfinished Metro pylon, the station entrance is unmissable.




3_30_10_w.jpg
 


Back
Top