Rail Claimore
New member
Japan is a different paradigm from even Europe when it comes to transit.
^Do you notice huge, dramatic differences with Canada or Australia, where they didn't build a superhighway network?
Aren't the British Rail lines out of London privatized? Such as the SouthWest Trains and the others too. All of which in an integrated fare system, including London Transport.
^You do realize that U.S. highways are paid for entirely by their users, don't you? It's just that a gas tax is easier to collect than a toll for each use.
User taxes pay about 2/3ds of the cost of all streets and highways. Now since we had local streets long before we had autos, and since the volumes (and therefore the gas burned) are so much higher on highways than on local streets, I think the proper way to interpret that is to say that motorists pay the entire cost of highways and about half the cost of local streets.
My point about Canada and Australia was not about the intercity highways and empty spaces in between cities, but about the urban areas. The density and form they took, even without a national superhighway program, is almost indistinguishable from metro areas in the U.S.
Any proof to back that claim up?Very very few public transit systems in the world make money. Even Europe with high density cities, etc does not have public transit systems that make a profit.
The federal government pours money into the Interstate highway system to match state spending and overcome the gap between gas tax revenue and necessary funding.
Any proof to back that claim up?
Otherwise I don't know why private companies are standing in line for PT concessions.
This federal money also comes (mostly) from gas taxes. Motorists—not other taxpayers—are paying the entire cost of the Springfield interchange, as well as most of the cost of the Second Avenue Subway. Because of the flows between levels of government and different programs, the only way to really examine the question is to look at the overall national picture, as the FHWA tables try to do. The table headings can be misleading; they use the word highways to indicate all roads, including local streets. The figure varies from year to year, but usually between 60 and 70 percent of all money spent on all streets and roads comes directly from motorist user fees.
The Department for Transport has seized control of the failed £1.4bn National Express East Coast franchise. Apart from a stint running the Southeastern service earlier in the decade, the government has ducked complaints over fare hikes and poor catering by letting the private sector take the flak – and the profits.
That will change when the DfT launches the frugally titled East Coast franchise with the aim of keeping the route under public ownership for at least 18 months while funnelling the proceeds into its coffers.