Privatizing transit?


^Do you notice huge, dramatic differences with Canada or Australia, where they didn't build a superhighway network?


Could they ihave built such a network if they wanted to? Both Canada and Australia are about the size of the 48 states, but with a smaller population than the state of California. Do they have enough people to justify building one?
 
Canada's federal government is too weak to do it, and highways aren't part of its mandate anyway. (It has no constitutional authority to build them; the Trans-Canada was built by the provinces, the federal government simply designated parts of their highway networks as Trans-Canada. It is less of a highway system than the Great River Road.) Canada is one of only a handful of nations where the sub-federal units have more money and power than the federal level, the only thing our national government can do is "co-ordinate an effort"; which they did with the Trans-Canada. Their responsibilities in this field, as far as their concerned, are complete.

We have enough people to justify Interstate style highways in parts of Canada. Ontario's freeway system (the 400-series) is pretty much identical to Interstates. (The province is a leader in safe highway design.) Cities like Edmonton and Calgary have ring roads and spokes similar to the Interstate networks in many US cities, Québec has a system that is as extensive as (if not more extensive than) the Interstate in many states (though it has been underfunded for years and is in poor condition). Several provinces (Saskatchewan, Manitoba and New Brunswick in particular) have all or most of their main highways divided at the very least, and minimum speed limits over 100km/h. A national-scale interstate system serving every major city, however, would be almost impossible for this country, an in many places, like Northern Ontario where even the Trans-Canada has less than 2,000 daily vehicles in many places, it would simply be fiscally irresponsible. Many people in the North don't even have cars, so there is little reason to build highways there. I don't even see it helping national unity, as the federal government encroaching on provincial responsibilities would just upset Québec.

As for how our cities were designed, we took a lot of our inspiration from what was being done in the United States. They built suburban tract housing, so we built suburban tract housing. They were building high capacity roads and freeways in their cities, so we built high capacity roads and freeways in our cities (and unlike the US where eminent domain was used to build those highways and there was little opponents could do, MANY of Canada's proposed freeways through urban cities were opposed enough to be cancelled. At least 5 in Toronto, and one through downtown Winnipeg that I know of). When Americans jumped on the bandwagon of converting downtowns to shopping malls, we joined them, and when they stopped, we stopped. The US is a nation ten times our size, there is a lot of influence from them. We didn't copy them entirely though. Our suburbs are more compact, our downtowns have more people, white flight wasn't as much of a problem and having a considerable amount of public run transit systems when American private transit was being bought out and shut down prevent our systems from becoming almost irrelevant. In fact, the main reason many Canadian cities shut down their street car systems is because American cities were doing it, not because they were bought out. We're similar but not identical, and that minor difference has, at least as far as public transit is concerned, produced quite a different result in our two countries. The lack of federal control over highway planning prevented us from getting to where the US is today.
 
Aren't the British Rail lines out of London privatized? Such as the SouthWest Trains and the others too. All of which in an integrated fare system, including London Transport.

The British overground train system was privatised in the early 1990s, with a private company taking responsibility for the tracks etc. and other franchises being responsible for running the train services along certain routes.

Overall, privatisation has been a pretty mixed bag:

  • The company running the tracks was renationalised after a fatal crash in 2000 showed that the rail network nationally had deteriorated to a very dangerous state. Although this process may have begun before privatisation, the fact that rail maintenance had been subcontracted and re-subcontracted through several different layers damaged public confidence considerably.
  • The companies that took over the rail franchises were expected to deliver much better service, but that hasn't really materialised. For example, Virgin took over one franchise, with the promise of transferring its high standards of customer service to the rail network, but the infrastructure was so poor that trains still kept running late - there was even one press story about passengers spontaneously bursting into applause when a train arrived on time.
  • Elsewhere, promises of new investment haven't always lived up to expectations - on the line I use, the rail operator bought a load of new trains, then scrapped them a few years later because they kept breaking down. The workhorses of the UK's long distance network are still trains built in the 1970s as a stopgap, before state-of-the-art high speed trains could be developed.
  • The Government still pumps in a huge subsidy into the rail network, to maintain less popular routes and to pay for the massive work needed to bring the 19th century infrastructure up to scratch.

The UK rail network isn't bad by international standards, but it isn't great either. Privatisation may help to raise standards on popular routes, but it is difficult to introduce meaningful competition into train travel, because, unlike air travel, customers don't really have a choice between different carriers. I don't think many people in Britain think that going back to a nationalised system would make things much better, but it wouldn't make things much worse either. The critical factors in the quality of public transport is the state of the infrastructure that has been inherited, and the strength of the collective desire of people to see a good service.
 
^You do realize that U.S. highways are paid for entirely by their users, don't you? It's just that a gas tax is easier to collect than a toll for each use.

User taxes pay about 2/3ds of the cost of all streets and highways. Now since we had local streets long before we had autos, and since the volumes (and therefore the gas burned) are so much higher on highways than on local streets, I think the proper way to interpret that is to say that motorists pay the entire cost of highways and about half the cost of local streets.

My point about Canada and Australia was not about the intercity highways and empty spaces in between cities, but about the urban areas. The density and form they took, even without a national superhighway program, is almost indistinguishable from metro areas in the U.S.

The federal government pours money into the Interstate highway system to match state spending and overcome the gap between gas tax revenue and necessary funding. The rate is exponentially higher than that for Amtrak and metropolitan transport projects. For example, the federal government is giving $676m to the rebuilding of the Springfield Interchange in Northern Virginia (a single interchange), but only $1.3bn for the Second Avenue Subway. So an interchange gets half the amount of a massive subway line. I don't get it.

Tolling works better than fuel taxes in some ways. When people actually see that they're forced to pay to get on the road to begin with, it's more of a deterrant than $4 gasoline (which Americans think is ungodly expensive).
 
There are already many individual routes in both Canada and the US that make a profit. But an entire system? Never. Entire systems can never be privatized.

There is no point in privatizing individual routes either. If public routes can be run profitably already, how is it beneficial for a private company to operate them? If such profitable routes are privatized, the government loses revenue and therefore will have to cut service for the remaining system. Privatizing transit just doesn't make sense in North America (and it probably does make sense in Europe either, for that matter).
 
As I stated in my post about Denver's system... PPP's are going to be leased out (prior to construction), on a couple of the EMU lines to a company to Design-Build-Operate-Maintain the line. As a result, there will be ~1 billion in local public funding via sales tax, ~$1 billion in Federal funding and ~$1 billion in private funding.

In exchange for the nearly ~$1 billion in private funding, the company is awarded the full contract to manage and sub-contract out it's Design-Build and then will have rights to collect revenue for 50-years from the operation of the line.

Originally, the extra ~$1 billion in private funding was not even needed. However, with sales tax collection massively below projections and building costs much higher than in 2004 (when cost estimates were conducted), the Private funding may well be the savior for the full build out of Denver's FasTracks system.

Without the private funding for these two EMU lines, they will still get built, the funding can cover them. However, it's the other two proposed DMU lines which would not have funding to get built. With nearly ~$1 billion in private contribution in form of the PPP, all lines should still get built, especially of a new additional tax increase is passed next year. If that tax is passed, then all the lines will be built by 2018 and they will all get a little meat put back into them.

So my point is, there is a point in privatizing mass transit lines!
 
Very very few public transit systems in the world make money. Even Europe with high density cities, etc does not have public transit systems that make a profit.
Any proof to back that claim up?

Otherwise I don't know why private companies are standing in line for PT concessions.
And I know for a fact that the national rail is making a profit so...
 
The federal government pours money into the Interstate highway system to match state spending and overcome the gap between gas tax revenue and necessary funding.

This federal money also comes (mostly) from gas taxes. Motorists—not other taxpayers—are paying the entire cost of the Springfield interchange, as well as most of the cost of the Second Avenue Subway. Because of the flows between levels of government and different programs, the only way to really examine the question is to look at the overall national picture, as the FHWA tables try to do. The table headings can be misleading; they use the word highways to indicate all roads, including local streets. The figure varies from year to year, but usually between 60 and 70 percent of all money spent on all streets and roads comes directly from motorist user fees.

Only a few train and transit lines anywhere in the world operate without a government subsidy: Hong Kong's MTR (because it was given a lot of developable land for free), a couple of tourist railroads in Switzerland, and a few lines in Japan that see very heavy ridership but by historic accident are not part of a larger network. In any large city, it's possible to identify a few line-haul routes that cover their marginal operating costs, but they are nearly always "dragged down" by off-hours or less-patronized lines that make the network much more useful. I don't know what "PT concessions" vendors are standing in line for, but they are almost certainly either the aforementioned nominally profitable line-haul routes, or they are purchase-of-service agreements in which they are essentially guaranteed a profit by the government agency.
 
Any proof to back that claim up?

Otherwise I don't know why private companies are standing in line for PT concessions.

...generally they're standing in line to get an immense subsidy from the government, either directly in the form of cash payments or indirectly via control of assets that the government has already paid for. 'PPP' in the transportation context is almost always just another form of corporate welfare - but it can still be justified in the rare occasions when the concession agreement is structured such that (1) the term is short enough to incentivize strong performance early on, and (2) the private operation actually is more cost efficient than a public operation.
 
intransit2u

This federal money also comes (mostly) from gas taxes. Motorists—not other taxpayers—are paying the entire cost of the Springfield interchange, as well as most of the cost of the Second Avenue Subway. Because of the flows between levels of government and different programs, the only way to really examine the question is to look at the overall national picture, as the FHWA tables try to do. The table headings can be misleading; they use the word highways to indicate all roads, including local streets. The figure varies from year to year, but usually between 60 and 70 percent of all money spent on all streets and roads comes directly from motorist user fees.

Gas taxes cover 1/5 of road expenses, also the street infront of your home is not being judged on a profit or loss basis for it's existance.

For that matter freeways make up less than 2% of roads in the US.
 
The last thing such privatization enthusiasts are interested in is improving service and being polite. Newly privatized employees who take pay and benefit cuts in the name of efficiency cannot be expected to be pleasant about their plight, either to their new bosses or to their customers.

Calls to privatize urban mass transit systems must be seen as just part of an overall agenda that won't be satisfied until it gobbles up every public asset created with taxpayers' funds. That includes electric and water utilities, community hospitals, public schools, highways and bridges, and other assets that make up the public commons.
 
Looks like there is one less privatized line to point to:

The Department for Transport has seized control of the failed £1.4bn National Express East Coast franchise. Apart from a stint running the Southeastern service earlier in the decade, the government has ducked complaints over fare hikes and poor catering by letting the private sector take the flak – and the profits.

That will change when the DfT launches the frugally titled East Coast franchise with the aim of keeping the route under public ownership for at least 18 months while funnelling the proceeds into its coffers.
 
Last edited:


Back
Top