Parking problems...


I always hear community groups in older neighborhoods claim that there are parking "problems" that need to be "solved". I'm talking about older neighborhoods that were built in the prewar era.

It always gets me that these neighborhoods have functioned just fine for several decades, but now they're problematic?

These same community groups want every new construction project to have tons of parking because of the "problems" these older (and often wonderfully beautiful) buildings create.

Has our society just completely lost it? And if the "solution" is to create more parking, then doesn't that kill the charm of the neighborhood to begin with? :koko:
 
the lack of parking "problem" is not limited to the charming prewar neighborhoods. it also afflicts brand new fairly high-density (however suburban) developments where residents bought units knowing full well the amount of parking provided (2:1 in garage, plus a certain number of on-street guest spaces), yet complained to the city council to do something about the "parking shortage", as was the case in nearby dublin (CA). i would think if one was looking at a particular project and found it did not have the amount of parking one (or any other aspect) desired, one would move on to something else--and not buy the damn thing and then cry to the city council. indeed, society has lost *it*.
 
Has our society just completely lost it? And if the "solution" is to create more parking, then doesn't that kill the charm of the neighborhood to begin with? :koko:

Here is a scenario that lays itself out over and over across many medium-sized cities in America:

A city sees a lot of downtown activity, but needs more parking for suburbanites to get in. So, they tear down a few historic buildings and create parking lots, simultaneously making the downtown more auto-friendly and less pleasant to walk around. It works, and more people drive into downtown, quickly filling up those spots. So, the city does it again. And again. Tearing down buildings, creating parking. Eventually, the city reaches a point to where there is so much parking that the downtown no longer has a pedestrian-friendly atmosphere, and no one wants to go downtown anymore. Then the city is fully capable of meeting its parking needs because there are no more people. It's often referred to as "Pensacola Parking Syndrome" after one of its early victims.
 
for the same reason that the answer to traffic congestion is always more highways.

cause people simply just dont get it... also old people like to complain.
 
A few years ago here in South Bethlehem, my old roommate and I had a huge parking problem. Not enough street parking? No; there was plenty, provided you lived on a block with permit parking, which allowed you to park wherever your corresponding permit allowed you to park. Say your block had Permit K parking; you bought a $10 annual Permit K and were allowed to park in any block with Permit K parking signs.

So where does the parking problem come in? For some fucking stupid reason, our block had no permit parking whatsoever; it was free parking to all. Permit parking is meant to allow residents and off-campus students to be able to have a parking spot in this kind-of college town without having to park really far away or circle around looking for spots. It's used for residential block.

The problem was we happened to live on a residential block. Plus, we were really close to the university as well as a bar. So as you can imagine, there was no parking available during class hours because students were able to park for free on our block. There was no parking whatsoever on Friday and Saturday nights because bar patrons parked their cars on our block. Fuck that; we had no parking whatsoever regardless of what time it was because people eventually found free parking. The worst thing was that our block was the only one without permit parking. :hell:

I decided to give up my car that year because of the lack of parking. Even with just my roommate's car, it was a difficult decision to, say, go grocery shopping or go out to eat because we had to figure out whether or not we could find parking when we got back.
We have permits parking now, but I gave up my car a long time ago...
 
In some ways I can think of ways where both scenarios by dchan and strongbad have played out in my town.

I think the reason why the issue can come up and then go away on it own has to do with random increases in business activity or residents in a neighborhood. A small restaraunt opens up in a formerly empty space and becomes hugely popular, and suddenly there aren't enough spaces anymore.
 
Lack of parking IS a legitimate problem that affects prewar downtowns. However, a better way to phrase the problem is "lack of access". In order for a downtown to thrive, people need to be able to get to its retail services, residences, and workplaces in sufficient volumes.

If the access capacity (parking + transit + pedestrian trips) does not meet the needs of the businesses downtown, then those businesses are not meeting their potential and so the downtown location is detrimental.

There are three ways out: either provide more parking, institute some form of public transportation, or add residents to the downtown, within walking distance, to patronize businesses and work in workplaces. Sometimes you can get creative: establish satellite lots in outlying areas and run shuttle buses, or build up with the parking to avoid demolition. Naperville has tried both of these.

Pedestrian-oriented developments are great, including historic prewar downtowns, but when most of the retail customers and workers come from auto-oriented places, then downtowns will have to accommodate the auto in some way, shape, or form. Unless massive physical transformation of the suburbs takes place, prewar downtowns and neighborhoods will always act as islands - only accessible by car, but pedestrian-oriented internally.
 


Back
Top