emathias
Adoptive Chicagoan
It seems to me that in any given region, transportation planning should be geared to optimizing speed-relative density. Ultimately, people don't just want to get places quickly to save time, they want to use increased speed to expand the range of services (which I use generically to include both things like grocery stores and jobs) they have access to.
Given a number of people, a given geography, and a survey of available technologies it should be possible to figure out what the optimum arrangement of transportation would be.
Simplified example:
Assumed average speeds:
Walking - 3 mph
Bus - 12 mph
Car - 25 mph (this does assume the existence of at least some expressways)
NOTE: I start with these three, because in a good system they all function similarly - they get you very close to your final destination in any direction. Some other possible inclusions, for example commuter rail, have limited stops and will often require modal transfers or limited geographical access which complicates the calculations.
With those speeds, if you assume that for a daily trip, the average person doesn't want to travel more than an hour from home, that gives you a daily trip area (radius squared multiplied by pi) of:
Walking - 28 square miles
Bus - 452 square miles
Car - 1,963 square miles
Then we can calculate densities in two ways:
First, densities needed to approximate the densities a walker has access to in central Paris, a place where people have excellent access to a wide range of services by foot.
Walking - 50,000 pop/sq/mi (the default rough Paris density)
Bus - 3,125 pop/sq/mi (this density can't usually support extensive bus service, but if it could, buses would give people access to similar services that a walker in Paris has)
Car - 720 pop/sq/mi (this is a density probably found in agrarian counties in the U.S.)
Second, effective access for each mode in an area with typical American suburban density - 3,500 pop/sq/mi. (density multiplied by daily trip area)
Walking - 84,000 people
Bus - 336,000 people
Car - 700,000 people
At Chicago's density of 12,000 sq/mi, the numbers become even greater - 288,000, 1,152,000, and 2,400,000, respectively.
Commentary:
Obviously this paints a pretty stark picture as to why people like having cars. Beyond pop-psychology reports of feelings of power or freedom, there is a practical effect, especially in larger metro areas, of having access to a wider range of services.
Calculating comparisons when integrating rail or for areas without comprehensive bus service increases the complexity, but I think the numbers demonstrate where the challenges are. Buses will nearly always be slower than cars, unless they have dedicated, strongly-enforced lanes and car traffic is just comparatively atrocious, and even a few mph difference can greatly increase access.
The other point is that in smaller, isolated metro areas, of 50,000 people or so over an hour away from anywhere else, just about any mode can max out the available services, so there may actually be less pressure to own a car there than in a big city -even a big city with comprehensive bus service.
Given a number of people, a given geography, and a survey of available technologies it should be possible to figure out what the optimum arrangement of transportation would be.
Simplified example:
Assumed average speeds:
Walking - 3 mph
Bus - 12 mph
Car - 25 mph (this does assume the existence of at least some expressways)
NOTE: I start with these three, because in a good system they all function similarly - they get you very close to your final destination in any direction. Some other possible inclusions, for example commuter rail, have limited stops and will often require modal transfers or limited geographical access which complicates the calculations.
With those speeds, if you assume that for a daily trip, the average person doesn't want to travel more than an hour from home, that gives you a daily trip area (radius squared multiplied by pi) of:
Walking - 28 square miles
Bus - 452 square miles
Car - 1,963 square miles
Then we can calculate densities in two ways:
First, densities needed to approximate the densities a walker has access to in central Paris, a place where people have excellent access to a wide range of services by foot.
Walking - 50,000 pop/sq/mi (the default rough Paris density)
Bus - 3,125 pop/sq/mi (this density can't usually support extensive bus service, but if it could, buses would give people access to similar services that a walker in Paris has)
Car - 720 pop/sq/mi (this is a density probably found in agrarian counties in the U.S.)
Second, effective access for each mode in an area with typical American suburban density - 3,500 pop/sq/mi. (density multiplied by daily trip area)
Walking - 84,000 people
Bus - 336,000 people
Car - 700,000 people
At Chicago's density of 12,000 sq/mi, the numbers become even greater - 288,000, 1,152,000, and 2,400,000, respectively.
Commentary:
Obviously this paints a pretty stark picture as to why people like having cars. Beyond pop-psychology reports of feelings of power or freedom, there is a practical effect, especially in larger metro areas, of having access to a wider range of services.
Calculating comparisons when integrating rail or for areas without comprehensive bus service increases the complexity, but I think the numbers demonstrate where the challenges are. Buses will nearly always be slower than cars, unless they have dedicated, strongly-enforced lanes and car traffic is just comparatively atrocious, and even a few mph difference can greatly increase access.
The other point is that in smaller, isolated metro areas, of 50,000 people or so over an hour away from anywhere else, just about any mode can max out the available services, so there may actually be less pressure to own a car there than in a big city -even a big city with comprehensive bus service.