M.T.A. Expands an Effort to Decrease Subway Trash


M II A II R II K

Active member
M.T.A. Expands an Effort to Decrease Subway Trash


August 30, 2012

By MATT FLEGENHEIMER

Read More: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/31/n...t-to-remove-trash-cans.html?_r=2&ref=nyregion

The evidence has piled beside turnstiles and beneath benches, along subway platforms where riders found nowhere else to place their coffee cups or apple cores and on the tracks where tattered newspapers and crushed bottles seem to have taken up permanent residence.

Yet despite some riders’ resourceful disposal methods since trash cans were removed from two subway stations last year, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority says the counterintuitive plan has worked: trash hauls have decreased, it said, and the stations are cleaner. As a result, the authority said, the pilot program has been expanded to eight more stations, including stops at 57th Street in Manhattan, Brighton Beach in Brooklyn, and East 143rd Street in the Bronx.

“I’m actually very intrigued by this,” said Joseph J. Lhota, the transportation authority’s chairman, before urging riders to treat the subway “as you would treat your home.”

Asked if the measure could eventually be extended into a systemwide policy, Mr. Lhota said, “It could be.” At the two stations that have been without trash bins since last fall — the Eighth Street and Broadway station in Greenwich Village and the Flushing-Main Street station in Queens — the number of trash bags hauled out by workers has decreased by 50 percent and 67 percent, the authority said.

Officials have described the logic of the program simply: If there is nowhere to discard trash, riders will take it with them — often outside of a station. Mr. Lhota said that prohibitions on garbage bins had been effective on the Underground in London and on the PATH system, which has been without bins since 2001 because of security concerns.

The transportation authority removes 14,000 tons of trash from the subway annually, it said. A spokeswoman for the city’s Sanitation Department said the reduction in trash at the two pilot locations had not burdened its collection operations at street level. “Sanitation has monitored these two locations and there has been no negative impact,” the spokeswoman said. Some riders, though, have expressed reservations about the plan. Less trash, they argue, does not imply a more hygienic subway experience.

.....




GARBAGE1-articleLarge.jpg
 
They also need to refurbish many or almost all of NYC's subway stations. They all look unfinished and could use a boost from the 20th century. At least make them similar or better than PATH's stations. Also, if it can be done, reconfigure the tracks so that the express trains can run faster and get back on that project to build a tunnel from Brooklyn to Staten Island so that the subway could combine with the existing railroad. These initiatives can save NYC from excess traffic but it can also increase the rate of mass transit that already exists as the largest in the country. It can also increase the city's walkability and lower the need for a car even more.
 
Less trash, but it makes using the subway a less convenient experience. NYC doesn't have to care because the subway is so dominant, but other cities where public rail systems have to compete with other modes of transportation should think twice.
 
The trash will probably end up on the tracks eventually, which will cause more track fires and system delays. Difficult to see this becoming effective in the long term.
 
My guess is their water bill would also go down if they ripped out all of the toilets and urinals.



Shut off the lights and cut that electric bill! Commuters can bring a flashlight or stay home!
 
Is the origin of that subway smell what happens when 1500 volts of direct current pass through a Starbucks Venti cup with a rat inside?
 
Is the origin of that subway smell what happens when 1500 volts of direct current pass through a Starbucks Venti cup with a rat inside?

No, its when it passes through a Strabucks Venti cup, with a rat inside, buried under a a pile of discarded AA batteries.


BTW, does this really need it's own thread? There's a perfectly good NYC transit thread to use.
 
I don't care much about trash. The worst is the bums and drunks that piss in the stations. Cities with open stations (like DC) don't have this issue. But for the old school stations there's plenty of things to hide behind and the station smells can get bad. Then when they clean up, the disinfecting chemicals are harsh and potent. I've been in a station where they were power-washing and the soap fumes made me want to rip my eyes out.

They don't have to get all fancy, just order up a cheap porta-john that can be cleaned with a power hose often and completely flushed by a valve connected to the sanitary sewers. You'd of course hope they'd fit in the elevator to get the toilets to the lower level. Many stations historically had washrooms but the permanent nature of them made them targets of persistent graffiti and vandalism that is difficult to repair in more recent decades.
 
I don't suppose platform doors will be appearing any time soon. It would at least block off the tracks and even keep the rats at bay trapped there.
 
They also need to refurbish many or almost all of NYC's subway stations. They all look unfinished and could use a boost from the 20th century. At least make them similar or better than PATH's stations.
So a system encompassing 468 stations that carries over 1.6 billion riders per year should refurbish itself to the standards of a 13 station, 75 million ride system?

Give them a good powerwashing, basic upkeep and be done with it. Spend the money on what truly matters, safety/reliability/speed/rail sets.
 
I don't suppose platform doors will be appearing any time soon. It would at least block off the tracks and even keep the rats at bay trapped there.

Platform doors are only feasible if the trains are capable of stopping exactly at those doors every single time.
 
And in the US these old systems have to remain in a state of disrepair, and appear ugly and dirty and backward compared to more modern systems. Including old systems that bothered to clean up and modernize.
 
It is the case that anything to do with heavy rail development in the US sucks.

Old systems like London continue to expand and take on engineering challenges, and are not left with old neglected stations that stink like piss. Anywhere else has decent mass transit expansion and the US having it doesn't belong in the same sentence. Even the so called high speed rail trains will have the ability to travel at those speeds but won't get a chance to.

And there are those so called new Chicago subway trains. They look like new versions of the old trains with a few extra bells and whistles, but there are not walk through articulated. Unlike the new Toronto subway trains where every nuance to the senses emphasizes that it's a far superior train than the one that preceded it. And the London S version of tube trains are of the same tech.
 


Back
Top