Lost Train Stations


Buffalo is a huge travesty, the original Buffalo Central Terminal:

Buffalo-Central-Terminal1.jpg


and, wait for it....











Their current "station":

buffalo_exchange1.jpg



The backstory is that they want to bring HSR or redevelop the original BCT, here is more information and I hope they succeed!:

http://buffalocentralterminal.org/
 
Probably the most magnificent train station left undemolished is Detroit's Michigan Central Station:

michigan-central-station-by-motionblur.png


And the current turd is here:

detroitstation1.jpg
 
While the renovation looks...nice...from the photographs there was a certain flair in the Milwaukee Amtrak station's Brutalism.

I find the renovation to be rather blah design-wise.

For one thing it looks like an actual train station and not just some shack by the tracks!
 
You really needed to encounter the old thing in person—although you can’t really tell from the picture, the concrete was pretty dirty, the arches gave the whole building a sort of morose de Chirico vibe from the street level, and the station’s interior was low and had that weird kind of brightly-lit by fluorescents that still felt kind of dark—none of which was helped by the presence of an even more gloomy brutalist post office next door and an elevated freeway across the street (both still there). In terms of passenger experience, the “new” station’s really much better. From the inside (where you can still see elements of the old station’s structure—from fta.dot.gov):

intermodal4.JPG


I’ll eventually put stuff up about Milwaukee’s other lost terminals (or someone else can beat me to it)—the ones that really were losses.
 
Lost Milwaukee Depots

The Milwaukee Road Depot

0302000471-l.jpg

http://images.wisconsinhistory.org/700003020024/0302000471-l.jpg

^ View of northern facade along Everett Street, between 4th and 3rd Streets (current site of We Energies Annex).

0404000177-l.jpg

http://images.wisconsinhistory.org/700004040013/0404000177-l.jpg

^ A northeastward view from the intersection of Clybourn and 5th Streets, looking toward the trainshed.


The Chicago & North Western Depot

0404000174-l.jpg

http://images.wisconsinhistory.org/700004040013/0404000174-l.jpg

^ A southeasterly view, looking toward the main streetside entrance at the foot of Wisconsin Avenue (current site of O'Donnell Park).


The railroads were forced to vacate their depots in the mid-1960s to facilitate planned freeway construction. Both railroads moved into a shared depot (posted earlier) elsewhere downtown. The Milwaukee Road's trackage leading up to its depot would have interfered with the flow of traffic from I-794 on/off ramps and reconfigured surface streets. The depot building itself was not going to be affected by freeway construction, and stood vacant for a very short time until a fire partially destroyed it, and was ultimately torn down completely. Across town, the Chicago & North Western's trainshed and lakefront trackage was slated for a freeway project that was ultimately never built (the Lake Freeway to Park East Freeway connection). Again, the depot building itself could have been spared, but the County could not find a buyer in time, and it was subsequently demolished.
 
the concrete was pretty dirty, the arches gave the whole building a sort of morose de Chirico vibe from the street level, and the station’s interior was low and had that weird kind of brightly-lit by fluorescents that still felt kind of dark.

"morose de Chirico vibe" - exactly how I'd describe all of Edward Durell Stone's buildings.

Stone didn't design the Milwaukee station, but he could have. It was actually designed by Edward L. Grieb & Associates, the primary Big Architecture firm in 1960s Milwaukee.
 
Before the Michigan Central Station/Depot/Terminal in Detroit, was the more centrally located Fort Street Union Station. Built in 1893, it was closed in 1971, and demolished in 1974.

Fort Street Union Station

UnionDepot.jpg

Link

Just a few blocks to the south of the Union Station was the original Michigan Central Railroad Depot, built in 1884, closed in 1913, and demolished in 1966.

(Old) Michigan Central Railroad Depot

mcs-old.jpg

ForgottenDetroit.com

(New) Michigan Central Railroad Depot

MCRRDepotView%5BJim%20BetancourtColl%5D.jpg

Michiganrailroads.com
 


Back
Top