Bus Question


Actually if the lead times are good and there is a central transfer point, there's no real reason to separate routes like that, unless your goal is to spend more money than necessary.

Yes, there are very good reasons. If you force everyone to go through the transfer point, you inconvenience the people who just want to bypass it.

Several routes in Portland are like that. The 4 serves Division St, then stop downtown for transfers, then continues on to North Portland. But the lead times are less than 15 minutes in any direction, so the single route very effectively serves more than one corridor.

Combining multiple routes into one is simply not a good practice. Different corridors have different levels of demand and a one-size-fits-all solution doesn't always work. Also, when routes are extremely long they can become extremely unreliable. Remember, a delay or disruption on one part of a route will affect the whole route. The running time of bus route should probably be no longer than 60 or 70 minutes in each direction.

Instead of looking at Portland, look at a city like Toronto. In Toronto, the bus service along the east-west arterial roads are arbitrarily split where they intersect with the north-south Yonge subway line. So the western portions of these corridors have completely different routes than the eastern portions, like for example, the 36 Finch West bus servicing Finch Avenue West and the 39 Finch East bus servicing Finch Avenue East. They service the same corridor, but different parts of that corridor. And there are good reasons for this, which I already explained.
 
Yes, there are very good reasons. If you force everyone to go through the transfer point, you inconvenience the people who just want to bypass it.



Combining multiple routes into one is simply not a good practice. Different corridors have different levels of demand and a one-size-fits-all solution doesn't always work. Also, when routes are extremely long they can become extremely unreliable. Remember, a delay or disruption on one part of a route will affect the whole route. The running time of bus route should probably be no longer than 60 or 70 minutes in each direction.

Instead of looking at Portland, look at a city like Toronto. In Toronto, the bus service along the east-west arterial roads are arbitrarily split where they intersect with the north-south Yonge subway line. So the western portions of these corridors have completely different routes than the eastern portions, like for example, the 36 Finch West bus servicing Finch Avenue West and the 39 Finch East bus servicing Finch Avenue East. They service the same corridor, but different parts of that corridor. And there are good reasons for this, which I already explained.

I think the point went over your head... you oversimplified my point, and I don't really feel like arguing.
 
I think the point went over your head... you oversimplified my point, and I don't really feel like arguing.

Au contraire, I think it was my point that went over your head. You argued against the splitting of routes into mutually exclusive routes even though I was talking about something completely different. When I said "multiple routes," I was talking about multiple overlapping and parallel routes as an alternative to having a single route deviating excessively from a corridor to do the work of multiple routes. I would have thought from the context of this thread that it would be obvious what I was talking about.
 


Back
Top