• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

Metropolitan area populations, 1940


Docere

New member
Metropolitan area populations, 1940 (500,000+)

1. New York 11,690,520
2. Chicago 4,499,126
3. Los Angeles 2,904,596
4. Philadelphia 2,898,644
5. Boston 2,350,514
6. Detroit 2,295,867
7. Pittsburgh 1,994,060
8. San Francisco 1,428,525
9. St. Louis 1,367,977
10. Cleveland 1,214,945
11. Montreal 1,145,282
12. Baltimore 1,046,692
13. Minneapolis 911,077
14. Toronto 909,928
15. Washington 907,816
16. Buffalo 857,719
17. Milwaukee 790,336
18. Cincinnati 789,309
19. Providence 711,500
20. Kansas City 634,093
21. Scranton 629,581
22. New Orleans 540,030
23. Houston 510,397
24. Hartford 502,193
 
Metropolitan area populations, 1940 (500,000+)

1. New York 11,690,520
2. Chicago 4,499,126
3. Los Angeles 2,904,596
4. Philadelphia 2,898,644
5. Boston 2,350,514
6. Detroit 2,295,867
7. Pittsburgh 1,994,060
8. San Francisco 1,428,525
9. St. Louis 1,367,977
10. Cleveland 1,214,945
11. Montreal 1,145,282
12. Baltimore 1,046,692
13. Minneapolis 911,077
14. Toronto 909,928
15. Washington 907,816
16. Buffalo 857,719
17. Milwaukee 790,336
18. Cincinnati 789,309
19. Providence 711,500
20. Kansas City 634,093
21. Scranton 629,581
22. New Orleans 540,030
23. Houston 510,397
24. Hartford 502,193

Here's a link to 1950 metro area pops and comparison to 1940. Table 2 contains ranking by size. https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/decennial/1950/pc-03/pc-3-03.pdf
 
Not directly comparable. It looks like it was in 1950 that the "eniire county except in New England" definition was adopted.
 
Here's a link to 1950 metro area pops and comparison to 1940. Scroll down to Table 2 for the good stuff. https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/decennial/1950/pc-03/pc-3-03.pdf

I believe the 1950 census was the first to use MSAs, so this won't be an apples-to-apples comparison. For example, the Boston number for 1940 seems larger than I would expect. The 1950 number for Boston is lower than the 1940, and it would've been very weird for any metro to have an actual decline in population that decade.
 
Wow, Scranton was almost a Top 20 metro. Now it couldn't even dream of matching Allentown. It's now a minor exurban mini-metro.

Great bones, though. At least they still have Dunder Mifflin.
 
Wow, Scranton was almost a Top 20 metro. Now it couldn't even dream of matching Allentown. It's now a minor exurban mini-metro.

Great bones, though. At least they still have Dunder Mifflin.

Joe Biden left in 1950 and it was all downhill from there.
 
Wow, Scranton was almost a Top 20 metro. Now it couldn't even dream of matching Allentown. It's now a minor exurban mini-metro.

Great bones, though. At least they still have Dunder Mifflin.


I wonder if there's something weird going on with the methodology there, as its metro only has 560,000 now. That or it just declined, which is also plausible. Either way it doesn't have quite the same historic heft to it that then-similarly sized cities like New Orleans or Kansas City do.
 
The Census Bureau adopted the more expansive MSA definition in 1950. That area has declined. Scranton is one of the few cities that peaked in population in 1930.
 
Last edited:
More of a cluster of industrial towns? Scranton had a population of 140,000 (and 76,000 today) in 1940. Wilkes-Barre is 20 miles away and also part of the area. It too lost about half its population (86,000 in 1940, 44,000 today).
 
Right, Scranton area is like a mini-version of Germany's Ruhr. There are maybe a dozen mining towns in a valley. Wilkes Barre alone is almost Scranton's equal. Essen is nothing like Frankfurt or Munich but the Ruhr is much more populous.

The Scranton core wouldn't have New Orleans' historical heft, but if you go out in the neighborhoods, I think their prewar heft looks roughly comparable.
 
^ 442,294 in the Atlanta metropolitan district in 1940.

ETA: We cross-posted. The metropolitan districts did not include entire counties.
 
metro atl was at 518,100 in 1940. slotted right between new orleans and houston. edit - actually that link austlar posted shows houston at 528, not 510; revised data?

interesting. says only 442k here https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/decennial/1940/population-volume-1/33973538v1ch04.pdf

Probably some revised criteria in 1950 census report (https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/decennial/1950/pc-03/pc-3-03.pdf), which I guess was using the new definition for standard metropolitan areas. In 1950 reoort includes Cobb County in the metro Atlanta metro total. The numbers for 1940 in 1950 census report don't always correspond with the numbers posted by Docere, but they seem to be pretty close. Both the 1940 and 1950 figures provide a great snapshot of where the country was in terms of urban population clusters in the period immediately before and after WW2. The changes since that period are pretty amazing.
 
Last edited:
The core to periphery shift in the US is quite striking. A majority of the population still lived in the East (i.e. the Northeast or Midwest east of the Mississippi River) in 1940. Today about a third of Americans do.
 
Compared to 2020 Census MSA numbers
Metropolitan area populations, 1940 (500,000+)

1. New York 11,690,520 /20,140,470
2. Chicago 4,499,126 /9,618,502
3. Los Angeles 2,904,596 /13,200,998
4. Philadelphia 2,898,644 /6,245,051
5. Boston 2,350,514 /4,941,632
6. Detroit 2,295,867 /4,392,041
7. Pittsburgh 1,994,060 /2,370,930
8. San Francisco 1,428,525 /4,749,008
9. St. Louis 1,367,977 /2,820,253
10. Cleveland 1,214,945 /2,088,251
11. Montreal 1,145,282 /4,291,732
12. Baltimore 1,046,692 /2,844,510
13. Minneapolis 911,077 /3,690,261
14. Toronto 909,928 /6,202,225
15. Washington 907,816 /6,385,162
16. Buffalo 857,719 /1,166,902
17. Milwaukee 790,336 /1,574,731
18. Cincinnati 789,309 /2,256,884
19. Providence 711,500 /1,676,579
20. Kansas City 634,093 /2,192,035
21. Scranton 629,581 /567,559
22. New Orleans 540,030 /1,271,845
23. Houston 510,397 /7,122,240
24. Hartford 502,193 /1,213,531
 
Toronto and DC were pretty much identical in size then and had remarkably similar postwar growth trajectories.
 


Back
Top