• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

What is the least "WASP" city in the United States?


Docere

New member
Among the major metros, my nstinct says NYC - no metro seems to have such a low percentage of WASPs among its white population. Percentage of overall population might be Miami or L.A. though given that they have such a low white percentage overall.

Also depends on how "WASP" too - strictly whites with mostly British Isles ancestry (and no other ethnic identity) or does it include all the northwest European Protestant groups?
 
Using your definition, a more interesting discussion might be had determining what is still the most WASP city in the US, city and/or metro.
 
Using First Ancestry (2013 is the latest available) to avoid overlap and add some groups together. In other words, this is people's primary identity.



Boston

Irish 16%
British/American 11.9%
Italian 10.5%

Chicago

German 9.8%
Irish 7.1%
Polish 6.8%
British/American 6%
Italian 5.2%

New York

Italian 11%
Irish 6.8%
British/American 6.3%
German 3.9%

Philadelphia

Irish 13%
Italian 10.9%
German 9.9%
British/American 8.6%
 
Miami is probably among the least Waspy. Whites in general are a small minority and most of the white population is Jewish/Italian/Russian.
 
Among the major metros, my nstinct says NYC - no metro seems to have such a low percentage of WASPs among its white population. Percentage of overall population might be Miami or L.A. though given that they have such a low white percentage overall.

Also depends on how "WASP" too - strictly whites with mostly British Isles ancestry (and no other ethnic identity) or does it include all the northwest European Protestant groups?

I would say any white person who is not a Catholic at this point. Most whites are no longer 100% of anything and are pretty mixed.
 
There's been a major decline in Catholic identity in Boston/Massachusetts over the past two decades. Remarkably Boston looks more like San Francisco or Seattle in it's % declaring no religion than other "northern ethnic" cities like New York, Philadelphia or Chicago.
 
Highly doubt it's anywhere in the northeast, since that's the WASPiest region in the entire country.

The Northeast is the least "WASP" region of the US.

Among white Americans, you sort of have an Anglo-Saxon South, German Midwest and Pennsylvania, and Irish/Italian Catholic Northeast.
 
New Orleans? High minority population, and unlike the rest of the Protestant south, has a significant Catholic population. I'm not sure about the Anglo ancestry, though. Is there a high French/Cajun heritage in the NOLA metro, like in rural Louisiana?
 
The Northeast is the least "WASP" region of the US.

Among white Americans, you sort of have an Anglo-Saxon South, German Midwest and Pennsylvania, and Irish/Italian Catholic Northeast.

Are we talking Anglo-Saxon or WASP, though? Yes, I'd say that the northeast is less dominated by Anglo-Saxons, but WASPs in the U.S. context are of British ancestry. New England is the epicenter of WASP culture in the United States. Technically, Donald Trump is not a WASP, or is at least only part WASP, because his father's family is German. The Bush family, New England natives, are the quintessential WASP family.
 
Never liked this acronym

Seems pejorative, for such a high achieving , inventive , socially and culturally fundamental group of Americans

Anyhow ,

Boston
Stamford
New haven
Greenwich / Fairfield county


Philadelphia is Quaker
New York is Jewish
Baltimore is catholic
Dc is episcopal
 
I would say any white person who is not a Catholic at this point. Most whites are no longer 100% of anything and are pretty mixed.

Eh, Eastern Europeans wouldn't fall under a WASP label either, I don't think. Unless by catholic you mean non-protestant.

As for the thread topic, I'd wager it's San Juan or Honolulu.
 
Last edited:
The Northeast is the least "WASP" region of the US.

Among white Americans, you sort of have an Anglo-Saxon South, German Midwest and Pennsylvania, and Irish/Italian Catholic Northeast.

The Northeast US is certainly very Catholic, but it is also the very epicenter of WASP culture.

Old money, Ivy League, country clubs, Wall Street, "society", elite private boarding schools, and dudes with first names like Whitaker or Goodman...etc. etc.

New Orleans? High minority population, and unlike the rest of the Protestant south, has a significant Catholic population. I'm not sure about the Anglo ancestry, though. Is there a high French/Cajun heritage in the NOLA metro, like in rural Louisiana?

New Orleans is a mix, more like a northern city is, but southern WASP culture is definitely prominent.
 
The Northeast is the least "WASP" region of the US.

Among white Americans, you sort of have an Anglo-Saxon South, German Midwest and Pennsylvania, and Irish/Italian Catholic Northeast.

I think he means culturally. WASPism's Vatican would be the East Side of Manhattan/coastal Fairfield County, CT. Park Ave. and Sutton Place were (and are still, to an extent) WASP strongholds. Even the Jews on Park are culturally WASP.

No one really talks about WASPs as a distinct group outside of the Northeast (probably in part because white anglo saxon Protestants aren't rare outside the Northeast, and because most WASPisms are associated with traditional Northeast elites).

So culturally, least WASP is probably somewhere like Miami or Dallas, with their flaunting, more is more, Sunbelt elites.
 
Like New Orleans, Baltimore is pretty low "waspy". Most of the whites are probably Catholic (often Italian, Irish, German, Slavic) and the non- white pop. is high.

The most "waspy" place might be the upper Maine coast, at least in summer. Places like Bar Harbor. The place reeks of old money waspiness, like Newport RI used to (not sure if it still does).
 
Last edited:
Are German Catholics considered "white ethnic" as well? If not, is it important to distinguish them from their Protestant counterparts like it is with the Irish?

I essentially interpret this question as what's the least British Isles, Germanic (German/Dutch/Belgian/Austrian/Swiss/Scandinavian), and maybe even French city, and to me it's clearly NYC. Anytime there's a New Yorker with a German surname, I automatically assume they're Ashkenazi Jewish; or they have a British-sounding last name (i.e. "As Good As It Gets" director James L. Brooks or Woody Allen) because their ancestors chose to Anglicize their legal identity when they immigrated.

I don't think being Catholic "matters" today if we're talking German, Irish, or French ancestry, as they are often intermixed with English, Scottish, or some other Western or Northern European group. On the other hand, Italian and Polish Americans tend to be less integrated and more overtly "ethnic." And in NYC, with its large Polish population, probably a decent share of them are Jewish.
 
Well, no... since eastern Europeans in the US are most often Catholic.

I guess that depends on if you consider Poland to be Central or Eastern European :).

Russians/Greeks/Serbs/Romanians/Moldovans/Ukrainians/Belorussians are all majority Orthodox. Croats/Slovaks/Slovenes/Hungarians/Lithuanians are majority-Catholic.

Of course Poles dominate all these groups.
 


Back
Top