Quote:
Originally Posted by emathias
The vast majority of people, even on this forum, don't travel just to see a tall building. They travel to visit a city, to experience the urbanity of a different city, to feel how different cities implement urbanity differently. Sure, if a city has an unusually tall building with an observation deck we may go visit it - but it's rarely the primary reason for going to that city, and most people would agree that if the only reason a city was famous was one tall building it would make for a very lame vacation.
|
Conversely, to a certain set of people, a tall building signifies that a city has the cultural and economic wherewithal to support its creation, and that this conceivably bestows a city with the attendant cultural capital. Obviously, this belief was established because, historically, those were the conditions that existed to provide the production of tall buildings (specifically, those buildings that were aspirational enough to test the limits of technology, economics, culture, etc.). The feedback from this phenomenon being that it's now exploited to give whatever city superficial credibility, and those that know this have busted the (skyline = city importance) equation. That being said, even adequately knowledgeable people know that cities can also have importance in industries that don't require sky-high buildings and that attract the people that produce the things that people are willing to travel to to consume (e.g., Boston).
In Chicago's case, it's an important part of our tourism appeal that we have landmark structures, because for better or for worse (and whether we still deserve it or not), our reputation is strongly associated with architectural prowess (if not singularly derived from it, in the case of international visitors).
The question, then, is whether it's important to attract those people or not. I'm of the position that it isn't, but I can't say one way or the other the level of importance it has and for how many people that would come here and contribute to our economy.