^Nailed it - 1.5 points. One point for the location and a half point for effort.
The McInness Building (1856-79) located at the south west corner of King and John. No idea what function the building served, though I'd guess it was a
manufactory of one sort or another. Any input is appreciated.
source
Subsequent to the immolation of this impressive pile, the city constructed the beauty below which, as Matt pointed out, was followed by Hamilton's present day courthouse/ post office in 1930.
source