Quote:
Originally Posted by chicago->denver
I’m not going to engage with the bulk of that passive aggressive straw man argument, dude. Equating terrorists and people with substance use problems is a false equivalence if ever there was one.
That small comment was intended to gently prompt you and perhaps others on here to consider that the folks we often dismiss as “druggies” (I’ve certainly been guilty of thinking that way, myself) are also people’s sons and daughters and brothers and sisters. My cousin, who was a kind, gentle, and loving young man, died of a heroine overdose at age 23. He had the horrible misfortune of developing the disease of addiction. Most of the people you see on the streets who are using drugs, much like my cousin was, don’t actually bother anyone. They just don’t have the ability to manage their addiction or a safe place to use in privacy. I wish they had more access to treatment and safe use sites, but they don’t.
I believe that the words we use matter. If the problem is “druggies,” then it’s natural to think the solution is “fences” or “police” to keep them away. If the problem is “neighbors, friends, and family members suffering from substance use disorders,” then the solution is a better system of support for addiction management, mental health treatment, assistance securing stable housing, and employment opportunities.
|
Listen to the impressive Psycho-babble.
Had someone recently pull the "Straw Man" argument on a Sports Blog. Apparently he had recently studied up on his fallacies so he thought he was a 'detection expert.'
It's perfectly fine to use analogies. A false equivalency depends partly on if one can't distinguish one from the other. I think we all understand what a terrorist is but that doesn't mean a comparison is without merit.
Drug Addiction is not a disease in the conventional sense
One who has contracted COVID, the flu or something even worse has an "intense craving" to get better and will do whatever is necessary or will help.
Whatever your solution is; It's not working
Opioid Addiction et al has been getting worse and worse and not better for many years. Whatever those who preach tolerance and treatment have been fighting a losing battler. Call Putin; he'll fix it.
How much money do you have invested in the $2 billion of RE investment in Union Square. How many $3,000 to $10,000 bikes have you had stolen knowing the cops can't help you because thief's get an automatic "Get out of Jail free card? How many retail businesses have you owned that went out of business due to 'shop lifting?' Talk about lack of empathy or comprehension.
I don't lack empathy or sympathy with respect to drug addicts. But People; Residents; Citizens; VOTERS want to 'hire' somebody who can fix the problem - or at the least show evidence that things are getting better and NOT WORSE.