Quote:
Originally Posted by simms3_redux
I'm less a fan of Stern than I was, but how can you not LOVE 15 Central Park West? I think unfortunately in this building's case, two things against it architecturally in my mind:
1) From my lay person's perspective it seems to copy almost verbatim 30 Park Place downtown. Lame (and I prefer 30 Park Place for a host of reasons)
2) The north-south angle is fine, even if it's a copy of 30 PP and has that traditional "Stern for the wealthy" look repeated time and time again. However, it is WAY too skinny from the east-west angle!! I don't like a tower this tall being so lopsided in dimensions.
My humble opinion.
|
I like the skinny aspect as seen from the east and west. It looks elegant. And we knew the building would be as wide as possible facing the Park, for obvious reasons. I'd like to see a bit more detail in the exterior, but for me, that's true of most of Stern's designs. And I think the crown could more refined, or could have a defining feature.
Overall, I think it's terrific. I just worry that 225 W 57th's Cthulhu architecture looming over it will lessen the impact of 220 CPS.