Quote:
Originally Posted by ethereal_reality
.I won't watch colorized black and white movies (I think it's wrong in so many ways) but the colorization works well in this instance.
_________________________________________________________________
|
It's interesting that when colorization first appeared in the 80's, the reception from almost all quarters was positive. Then some well-known directors, like Scorcese and Allen for two examples, began to complain about it, but over time it is still being done.
When I was growing up we didn't have a color TV for most of that time, so I grew up watching color TV series and movies in b&w and in the 70's and beyond discovered a lot of those things again anew in color, so, to me, colorizing something doesn't seem like that big a deal. It's just another way to see a film or TV series that one likes in a different way. (Conversely, I have watched some films I've liked in b&w, turning off the color, just to see what they've looked like that way. I've also watched some film favorites that I am really familiar with in different languages for the same reasons.)
Also, colorizing has immensely improved since the 80's. The first aired colorized version of Miracle on 34th Street on TV wasn't very good. Like
HossC, I have a set of the b&w and colorized Miracle on 34th Street and the redone version is really good and every year I gravitate more toward that one.
Colorization has also been used to good effect in documentaries, like Peter Jackson's WWI film, They Shall Not Grow Old. Which brings up why many people are against colorization because it wasn't originally made that way, but have absolutely no problem with film makers retooling the silent film speeds to look more natural, or redoing the sound on dozens or hundreds of old movies because they can make it sound better. Or using computers to align the 3-strip technicolor movies to be seen in a way no audiences did when they were originally released.
And who can argue that colorizing historical photos doesn't give them new life, new perspectives and an intimacy that b&w does not?
99 Stunning Colorized Photos That Breathe New Life Into The Past
https://allthatsinteresting.com/colorized-photos
Yes, I would never watch a b&w film I hadn't seen before colorized the first time I saw it.