Quote:
Originally Posted by summersm343
|
The phillyyimby article doesn't tell the whole story of this property. The new construction in the rear will take place where a historic building from 1753, the schoolhouse of the German Reformed Church still stands. (The current church building, dating from 1837, is next door at Race Street.) In trying to understand the project, it appears to me that this new development will add extra floors on top of the schoolhouse.
Normally, of course, it would be incorrect to alter a significant 270-year-old building in this manner. However, the old building, formerly 2 1/2 stories, was radically altered in the 19th century, and used for many years as a paint warehouse. So in this case, I think it is a good project. The historically styled additions, while they might not be authentic, would produce a rather handsome building that fits in with its surroundings. I am more nervous about the plans that the church has put forward to replace another building on the property, and to fill in its garden, with a modern-styled building on the corner of 4th & Race.