Quote:
Originally Posted by ScreamingViking
Brilliant? This is probably the most brilliant thing that has happened along the south side of King since AGH was renovated.
Judgment should definitely be reserved until the final product, but it looks like they're following the plan.
|
What does that say about the left side then if THIS is the most brilliant thing they have come up with, when liuna and core urban are KILLING it on the other side..?
Let's not set our standards too low here.. it's a glass box. Regardless of how they change it, it's going to remain a glass box.
look familiar? It's at mcmaster. A building like this is ok and acceptable at mcmaster.
Now compare.
They have basically just put a jagged facade on the exact same building. A building like this is ok anywhere else in the city, and I will reserve judgement until the end, but I just am amazed it passed considering it does not keep consistency with the design elements of literally everything around it - which has some element of stone or concrete all along this side. I get it was approved as a "facelift" to the existing building - but when they demolished it they had no reason to stay with the existing structures elements.
I dunno, I know it's just my opinion, but it irks me. Maybe itll be nicer inside - it's one thing hamilton has going for it is that a lot of dodgy places have beautiful interiors. I went by it today and they seem to be going for some mezzanine second floor stuff.. or maybe it just hasn't been finished yet. We shall see.
I should reiterate that I don't necessarily have an issue with the design ITSELF - these types are needed as infill throughout the city - I have an issue with it being put in the gore which is supposed to highlight the most impressive building architectural styles (of their time) imo. Everything else on that side is impressive in its own way. If it's not design, then it's height - and this one has neither. Mind you - their new philosophy that "no new buildings should prevent sunlight from entering gore park 50 years from now" might have attributed to a handicap in height...
and I know I know, I'm venting.. vent over.