NSP defends $58m building
By JUDY MYRDEN Business Reporter
Sat. Nov 8 - 12:14 PM
Nova Scotia Power has gone on the attack against opponents of its proposal to spend almost $60 million turning an old generating station on the Halifax waterfront into its new corporate headquarters.
The company says the province’s consumer advocate, John Merrick, and some industrial customers are "never satisfied by NSP’s diligence" and propose "a path of further delay and expense," the company wrote Tuesday in a brief to the Utility and Review Board.
Nova Scotia Power needs the review board’s approval to proceed with the project. The board oversees the company’s expenditures.
Two of the province’s largest pulp and paper companies and a group known as "Avon Valley et al" are among the project’s opponents.
Avon Valley wants the review board to reject the proposal and order Nova Scotia Power to submit another one after putting out a request for proposals. It also wants the utility to conduct an exhaustive negotiation with its current landlord and to compile a thorough cost analysis of the proposed new headquarters.
Nova Scotia Power responded that having a "tougher negotiation" with the landlord or issuing a formal request for proposals would not benefit its customers.
It says its proposed $58.2-million renovation is "$5 million less than the second-lowest-cost alternative" — building new offices outside the downtown core.
Its other option is to stay in Barrington Tower at Scotia Square, where it has rented space since 1971. Details of how much it would cost to stay there are blacked out in the documents, but Nova Scotia Power says it would be cheaper to renovate the old generating station. The Barrington Tower lease expires in March 2011.
"It is better to refurbish this property than continue to have customers pay the rental costs that would be owing to a landlord," the company said in its rebuttal evidence filed with the board.
The power company filed its application to the review board in July and is asking for a "timely" decision so construction can begin in January if the project is approved.
The review board’s consultant, Tim Margolian of DTZ Barnicke Atlantic Real Estate of Halifax, told the board in an Oct. 17 brief that renovating the old generating station is "the best alternative" among the options and would add value to the downtown core while locating the utility’s head office near government and professional services.
But Mr. Margolian raised concerns that the renovation project is under-budgeted and might face cost overruns.
The Water Street building would include six floors of office space and meeting rooms, and it would be home to about 400 employees.
Until a year ago, the building housed Electropolis Studios, one of Halifax’s premier film production houses. Electropolis moved to a Sackville Street location after failing to reach a deal with Nova Scotia Power to stay on Water Street.
(
jmyrden@herald.ca)