Quebec, the French Language, and Quebecois Identity


Status
Not open for further replies.
if Wigs were born and raised Québécois (and therefore would have some of this place's unique quirks ingrained in him)
That's a bit too much of an "if".

Might as well say that "if" Wigs had been born and raised in a Weimar Germany bled dry by the extremely harsh provisions of the Versailles Treaty, he would have voted for Adolf Hitler.

:P

The question is how Wigs would vote, not how Alternate-Universe-Wigs would vote :P
 
That's a bit too much of an "if".

Might as well say that "if" Wigs had been born and raised in a Weimar Germany bled dry by the extremely harsh provisions of the Versailles Treaty, he would have voted for Adolf Hitler.

:P

The question is how Wigs would vote, not how Alternate-Universe-Wigs would vote :P

PLQ for sure, then.
 
That said, Macron seems reasonably intelligent and literate (for a 2020s politician). I'm impressed.
Macron is haughty, and doesn't have a common touch. He's what we call "hors sol" in French, that's his problem. Parizeau in that interview didn't appear to me as "hors sol" and lacking common touch.
 
Macron is haughty, and doesn't have a common touch. He's what we call "hors sol" in French, that's his problem. Parizeau in that interview didn't appear to me as "hors sol" and lacking common touch.

I agree: Parizeau was very 'common man'. To the point of the filter that would have saved other politicians' skins was missing at key moments.

It was both his greatest asset and greatest flaw.

I do kind of want lobster for dinner now.

Edit: At least he had the good sense to keep his mouth mostly shut after he promised to leave politics.
 
(That was a rhetorical question, but you'd be correct answering "Miss Teen South Carolina 2007".) :P
No, I would answer "the Donald". Although I must say, despite his despicable morality and behavior, Trump does have a certain businesslike common sense that is refreshing at times.
 
Macron is haughty, and doesn't have a common touch. He's what we call "hors sol" in French, that's his problem. Parizeau in that interview didn't appear to me as "hors sol" and lacking common touch.

Emmanuel Macron is probably the most statesman-like, intellectual, sophisticated world leader of all of the world leaders I follow at the moment.

But yes he is very out of touch with the average person.

He is fairly unique right now in terms of the first characteristics, but not unique at all for the second ones.
 
Emmanuel Macron is probably the most statesman-like, intellectual, sophisticated world leader of all of the world leaders I follow at the moment.

But yes he is very out of touch with the average person.

He is fairly unique right now in terms of the first characteristics, but not unique at all for the second ones.

I'm trying to think of recent world leaders that had both characteristics: in-touch and intellectual at the same time.

Barack Obama? Jean Chretien? Bill Clinton? Any other ones? The list from European leaders is harder: Tony Blair maybe, but I'm mostly too out of touch for a comprehensive list.

I'm getting old.
 
Last edited:
No, I would answer "the Donald". Although I must say, despite his despicable morality and behavior, Trump does have a certain businesslike common sense that is refreshing at times.
I find Trump to be a much better orator than Trudeau, but again, that’s an extraordinarily low bar.

I agree on the refreshing businesslike common sense too. And on the despicable morality/behavior.
 
I'm trying to think of recent world leaders that had both characteristics.

Barack Obama? Jean Chretien? Bill Clinton? Any other ones? The list from European leaders is harder: Tony Blair maybe, but I'm mostly too out of touch for a comprehensive list.

I'm getting old.
Chrétien sophisticated?!?!?

Also, I’d put Hillary on your short list. (Having said that, I realized you were listing elected leaders only so that’s probably why you left her off the list.)
 
Chrétien sophisticated?!?!?

Also, I’d put Hillary on your short list. (Having said that, I realized you were listing elected leaders only so that’s probably why you left her off the list.)

This where I'd actually disagree with you.

Hillary is not 'in-touch' with the Average Joe of her country, but could be a sophisticated leader.

Bill was far more close to that mark of being 'in-touch' and 'sophisticated leader' at the same time. Barack Obama was the most clear example in more recent times for the United States.
 
That’s why I was disagreeing with most of your list :P The way I followed the conversation, the two characteristics we’re discussing is 1) intellectual and 2) out of touch with common folk. As Acajack said, the latter isn’t rare (Trudeau, Trump, etc.) but the former nowadays is less common than it used to.

In other words, Hillary is an example of Macron-like.
 
That’s why I was disagreeing with most of your list :P The way I followed the conversation, the two characteristics we’re discussing is 1) intellectual and 2) out of touch with common folk. As Acajack said, the latter isn’t rare (Trudeau, Trump, etc.) but the former nowadays is less common than it used to.

In other words, Hillary is another example of Macron-like.

Heh. I suppose I was unclear on that one. :P
 
It was probably partly an act, and partly real.

Which would seem to agree with my assessment, no?

If one can know how to balance the 'in-touch' appearance with Average Joe with the 'intellectual' aspect of being a statesman-like world leader, that's a rare bird.

Western European leaders strike me as more the 'intellectual' side, much less worried about the Average Joe of their country. However, I am not a local and can't truly say. Do they put on a 'face' that their countrymen only see? Probably.
 
I agree: Parizeau was very 'common man'. To the point of the filter that would have saved other politicians' skins was missing at key moments.

It was both his greatest asset and greatest flaw.

I do kind of want lobster for dinner now.

Edit: At least he had the good sense to keep his mouth mostly shut after he promised to leave politics.

I would have said the epitome of "U" rather than "common man". His anglophilia left a strange impression.
 
That's a bit too much of an "if".

Might as well say that "if" Wigs had been born and raised in a Weimar Germany bled dry by the extremely harsh provisions of the Versailles Treaty, he would have voted for Adolf Hitler.

:P

The question is how Wigs would vote, not how Alternate-Universe-Wigs would vote :P

:haha: I'm dying

Yes I voted Libs/Trudeau in 2015, but voted for NDP most recent election. Like most politicians Trudeau failed to follow through on many policies promised.
It's not uncommon in my region to alternate between those parties and some, in my political ideology cohort, even have voted Conservative in decades past, my father included (Provincially at least). Although like a Trump voter long removed he'll never publicly admit to that :haha:)

Thanks for the hypothetical assessments. You both made me chuckle.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.


Back
Top