TransitZilla
New member
Crews were working on laying ties between South Keys and Greenboro today for the future NB track. Also some work underway at the Elwood Diamond bridge (which I think is probably likely on the critical path for completion).
I drove out to Riverside South on Sunday. They are still grading the right of way and laying more stone. Winter is coming soon. Are we going to have the track laid before then? If not, I cannot see this project being completed before the start of the next academic year.
I still see Bowesville Station on a slope, which is truly strange. And it appears that the stations do not offer weather protection for the most of the length of the trains. Wait for the wind to be ripping, the rain pouring and the snow flying. It will be unpleasant at those stations.
Also, progress at Greenboro station has been at a glacial pace.
The big question? How will we address the last mile problem? For my trip on Sunday, the train doesn't serve either my start or end point. The walk is too far at both ends.
Last mile? Car.
I wish they would focus their attention on finishing South Keys to Bayview to get that done ASAP and return service to those who had been using the line for the 20 years. The south extension can wait.
This City is so focused on serving the suburbs that they forget or don't care about existing riders. We had 20k riding Line 2 before between the opening of Confed and Covid. How many of those 20k are riding the dismal R2? Then they wonder why we're all so frustrated with OC Transpo and ridership is not picking-up. It's not just the Feds slow return to work, it's the alienation of the long time customers.
I can't have a car at both ends, so obviously we end up with an unusable train system for most suburban trips.
After my infamous 1hr 40m experience with R2 because there was no hope in timing transfers, I have given up on R2 and have driven instead when I have been going in that direction. I'd rather pay exorbitant parking than putting up with the R2 unreliability.
It seems to me that the number of possible transit trips that are convenient are getting smaller all the time.
We need a team of people out there assessing efficiency of the system and polling customer complaints and looking for real solutions to improve transit travel times and reduce transfer wait times. It is stupid how we expect most trips to require the use of the Confed line. Our city is bigger than what one transit line can possibly offer efficiently.
While I live near the airport, it is crazy that I am expected to get to the CTC using the Confed Line via Bayview. Not even close to a straight line. This can never offer timely service.
We hear a lot of complaints about weather and wind protection at Line 1 stations, but at least frequency is high (for the train, at least, not connecting buses. Waiting 12 minutes in an open air station will be far less tolerable.
Last mile? Car.
I wish they would focus their attention on finishing South Keys to Bayview to get that done ASAP and return service to those who had been using the line for the 20 years. The south extension can wait.
This City is so focused on serving the suburbs that they forget or don't care about existing riders. We had 20k riding Line 2 before between the opening of Confed and Covid. How many of those 20k are riding the dismal R2? Then they wonder why we're all so frustrated with OC Transpo and ridership is not picking-up. It's not just the Feds slow return to work, it's the alienation of the long time customers.
This is such a painfully true statement. The work should have been parsed to go from Bayview to South Keys, Airport to South Keys and then stations name that I don't even care about in a field to South Keys. Not so much a 3 stage project exactly but just parlaying your workers as such. I've pointed out before how I only see a half dozen workers at time at both South Keys and Greenboro. It's insane how easily this could have happened from the comfort of my Corinthian leather computer chair.
RE: wind protection on Line 1.... once L1 and L3 are interlined, in between Lincoln Fields and Blair we should be seeing 2 or 2 1/2 minute service correct? That is my understanding. That would really negate the relatively small train cars and platforms in the central area.
You are being very optimistic. I don't see this happening. We were supposed to get 3 minute frequency and ended up with 5 minute frequency. Unless we get a big bump in ridership, why would they improve frequency beyond that?
Because now the trains will go to Orleans. The City wants to offer primo service to areas that don't use transit outside of rush hour.
The vast majority of Orleans residents don't live within walking distance of the line. We can hope for a ridership bump, but I wouldn't count on it. The same lousy bus connections will remain, and many bus routes will be further truncated, meaning that the bus routes will have even fewer transit destinations. I am not holding my breath that local buses will be improved. I have long advocated for 2 way loops so that local buses can depart to the same neighbourhoods on on offset schedules so that 30 minute frequency can actually be 15 minute departures from the LRT station. Sometimes you might take the long way around the loop, but the worst thing about transfers is the waiting time. We don't have the creativity to consider whether this is possible in places like Orleans. I contend that Orleans is the perfect place to experiment with 2 way loops.
I didn't say anything about ridership or improved bus connections. I'm saying the City will want to run frequent, mostly empty trains, to Orleans because the City's focus is not to build the most efficient transit system (i.e. where people actually use transit), it's only to serve suburbs.
In my experience living in Fallingbrook, bus service was good. Always on time, every half hour. Which is fine when you leave home and plan what time you get to the bus stop, but not as much when coming back. Also, fine as long as your destination is Place d'Orleans of Blair/O-Train and have a lot of time to kill.
Spending Billions converting perfectly functional commuter bus spines will not result in increased ridership. Driving is instilled in the suburban mindset, in large part because of the auto-centricity of how our suburbs our built. I honestly think bike lanes would have more of an impact on reducing car trips, but it is worth re-jigging some bus lines to serve detonations within the suburbs, not just milk runs to the O-Train.
Rapid transit in urban areas with mixed-incomes would have a far more significant impact on transit ridership. St. Laurent to Lincoln Fields will probably prove this, but those stats will never be released because it goes against the City's message and goals.
It's almost like the Trillium line is like a GO train with the southern and airport extension.
Adding Walkley and Gladstone is still pretty helpful. I miss riding Line 2... Frequency aside it was a such a nice train car with massive picture windows. They took it offline shortly after I moved to South Keys. I still walk to Greenboro station regularly. I can get to South Keys in 15 minutes. Loblaws and Greenboro is a short walk beyond that.
I am mildly annoyed and disappointed that Greenboro platform doesn't appear to have any type of overhead cover or sheltering once you walk off the bridge. The platform is also not even close to being centered with the bridge. Given that the park and ride lot is almost full even with reduced ridership these days I would have expected this station to be more than a concrete sidewalk adjacent to a set of train tracks. I guess we will see what undersized and unheated bus shelters they stick against the fence with a much too narrow passage in front.
Then you go over to Walkley station that has this insanely massive fully enclosed area with high ceilings and glass walls to descend from the road... and the platform will seemingly be just another sidewalk adjacent to train tracks.
It makes me really appreciate how well built and practical the SE Transitway is.
Line 2 feels more like inter-urban rail then intra-urban rail based on what I am seeing so far.
It's almost like the Trillium line is like a GO train with the southern and airport extension.
Adding Walkley and Gladstone is still pretty helpful. I miss riding Line 2... Frequency aside it was a such a nice train car with massive picture windows. They took it offline shortly after I moved to South Keys. I still walk to Greenboro station regularly. I can get to South Keys in 15 minutes. Loblaws and Greenboro is a short walk beyond that.
I am mildly annoyed and disappointed that Greenboro platform doesn't appear to have any type of overhead cover or sheltering once you walk off the bridge. The platform is also not even close to being centered with the bridge. Given that the park and ride lot is almost full even with reduced ridership these days I would have expected this station to be more than a concrete sidewalk adjacent to a set of train tracks. I guess we will see what undersized and unheated bus shelters they stick against the fence with a much too narrow passage in front.
Then you go over to Walkley station that has this insanely massive fully enclosed area with high ceilings and glass walls to descend from the road... and the platform will seemingly be just another sidewalk adjacent to train tracks.
It makes me really appreciate how well built and practical the SE Transitway is.
Line 2 feels more like inter-urban rail then intra-urban rail based on what I am seeing so far.
I am mildly annoyed and disappointed that Greenboro platform doesn't appear to have any type of overhead cover or sheltering once you walk off the bridge..
I would love to know what the deal with this tarp is. This photo is a few days old and I'm almost positive when I went by yesterday the tarps extended all the way down.
Any ideas on what they could need this for?
Also.. if anyone is wondering why the southern extension is delayed by a year it's because nobody works here. Granted there is the lower interior section I can't see but I have seen at a maximum 2 or 3 people at a given time. No trucks or activity in the yard etc.
It would have been nice if they staged the work in such a way that we could have had Greenboro to Bayview service by now and the rest of the work south of that to follow.
By the time this project goes live that will probably be 95% of your catchment anyways aside from park and ride and South Keys station itself.
Poor planning if you ask me. Sucks to be a foreign Carlton student who booked housing based on a school brochure.
There is going to be shelter, it's sitting on the platform, just not assembled yet
While they aren't exciting architecturally, (same shelters as the buses at Hurdman and Tunney's) I'd argue the shelters they are a slight improvement over what the line had before. They are fully enclosed with doors unlike the old shelters. I'm hoping they have heaters as well, there's no reason they couldn't, as oc transpo has installed heaters in shelters like that before at Fallowfield and Eagleson
I found that the glass roofs of the old Red-tube and Glass shelters was a bonus. The extra light they let in made the shelter seem less confining. When OC Transpo began exchanging the glass panels for aluminum ones (because of cost) the shelters began to feel much more ‘cave-like’. [I find it interesting that glass panels are again being used for over-head cover at the LRT stations. I suppose that OC Transpo figures that the replacement cost will fall on RTM. Of course, a big difference is that the new ‘shelters’ don’t use curved glass – so the new panels are much less expensive.]
But those old shelters were not perfect. The ‘Water-fall’ design of the roof was just that; a water-fall – or snow-/ice-fall – when there was precipitation. This was not pleasant for transit customers who wound up getting stalled during boarding – with water, or snow, being poured down their neck. The over-head shelter should have extended to over the buses. [Unfortunately, these might have needed modification when OC Transpo switched to Double-Deckers, since they would, likely, not have been originally built much higher than the, then current, buses.]
[I know that some will now bring up the tragic collision of the Double-Decker with the Westboro Station’s overhang. I suggest that, had the stations been properly designed, there would have been a proper ‘deflector’ included when the station was built. Such a safety requirement would have absolutely prevented any vehicle from mounting the platform.]