Hawrylyshyn
Active member
Montreal's public realm is on another level compared to the rest of Canada
They just installed a new mosaic mural. Pretty cool.
Why do they have to keep the steps closed to people though?
![]()
I just checked this area out on street view, and I just realized for the first time how much less visible Gardiner has become from the street level in Harbourfront.
Montreal's public realm is on another level compared to the rest of Canada
Montreal's public realm is on another level compared to the rest of Canada
Pound for pound, I would say the best public realm in Canada is in Vancouver.
If you go to any random sidestreet or park in an area where tourists never go, you'll find things like cohesive materials and design guidelines that are applied citywide. Things like decent sidewalks, curb bulbouts for pedestrians, attractive landscaping and planting, pavement in good condition, attractive lamp posts, etc.
Vancouver is probably the closest to a northern European city when it comes to general user-friendliness and design of its public spaces. Like in Northern Europe, the Oceanic climate certainly helps. I'm not one of those guys who uses climate as an excuse not to improve our public realm, but you can't deny that the eastern half of the North American climate subjects our spaces to a lot more challenges than what they face in Amsterdam. Snowplows chew up the curbs; aggressive weeds accidentally introduced from the Eurasian continent where they're native poke out of any sidewalk crack and take over lawns; road salt kills street trees.
I'd say Hull/Gatineau is the least complete of the cities I've truly experienced. Built for cars. Poorly maintained. Quality and design of buildings is sub-par (with a few exceptions). The contrast between Ottawa, which is quite mediocre outside the central area, and Gatineau is quite jarring. It has potential, but that hasn't been tapped.
We're definitely the worst in Quebec of all the major cities and even compare poorly to many of the smaller ones.
Not sure how much of Canada you have seen but we're actually not too bad or at least similar compared to a number other fairly large places, though.
Pound for pound, I would say the best public realm in Canada is in Vancouver.
If you go to any random sidestreet or park in an area where tourists never go, you'll find things like cohesive materials and design guidelines that are applied citywide. Things like decent sidewalks, curb bulbouts for pedestrians, attractive landscaping and planting, pavement in good condition, attractive lamp posts, etc.
Vancouver is probably the closest to a northern European city when it comes to general user-friendliness and design of its public spaces. Like in Northern Europe, the Oceanic climate certainly helps. I'm not one of those guys who uses climate as an excuse not to improve our public realm, but you can't deny that the eastern half of the North American climate subjects our spaces to a lot more challenges than what they face in Amsterdam. Snowplows chew up the curbs; aggressive weeds accidentally introduced from the Eurasian continent where they're native poke out of any sidewalk crack and take over lawns; road salt kills street trees.