Unpopular opinion I'm sure, but I support this plan and wish we had more like this along other traditional main streets. I do hope they slap some heritage preservation on a few buildings north of First, like the Chinese United Church and Ambassador Court (triangular shaped buff brick apartment building on the park) next door.
I dont like the cap at 4 stories. The seven-storey apartment building by Minto at Bank and Fifth Avenue shows exactly how to add density to the glebe without messing with the character of the neighbourhood IMO
The four-storey limit refers to 'street walls' which would encourage setbacks for higher floors, no? My understanding is that you could have a 20-story development but the tower section would have to be set back away from Bank.
The four-storey limit refers to 'street walls' which would encourage setbacks for higher floors, no? My understanding is that you could have a 20-story development but the tower section would have to be set back away from Bank.
So I think until house prices rise enough that creating a land assembly and going through a site plan & OP/SP amendment can be deemed profitable, development on bank will halt. but hey were not in a housing emergency right? lol,
I don't buy that argument. We have hundreds of acres of empty fields and parking lots waiting to be redeveloped. Dozens of massive approved and proposed residential projects that still haven't broken ground. I don't think we need to raise a traditional main street with no transit in order to get out of the housing crisis.
"no transit" isn't very accurate. No rapid transit maybe.
I don't buy that argument. We have hundreds of acres of empty fields and parking lots waiting to be redeveloped. Dozens of massive approved and proposed residential projects that still haven't broken ground. I don't think we need to raise a traditional main street with no transit in order to get out of the housing crisis.
City must intensify but not where I like the old built form....I think there's an acronym for that
The 4 story facade can still exist with a setback from the street and as for transit if this is as dense as bank is getting in this area then limited funds are better used elsewhere in the city that are seeing those increases in population, especially since those areas are also bringing in the majority of dev fees.
Sorry, have to take issue with your suggestion that we shouldn't invest in transit there. If you've been through Centretown, the Glebe and Old Ottawa South lately, you'd see that there is a ton of intensification happening in that corridor. When you look at the number of underdeveloped lots that still exist on or near Bank and the possibility of adding more housing at Lansdowne, there is all sorts of potential.
I'm not sure why you would argue against investing in better transit in areas that generate some of the highest transit ridership in the city (and not just commuter ridership). I would say that the failure to properly invest in urban transit is a big reason that OC ridership growth has been disappointing for years.
Lastly, I don't think that you can label someone who doesn't want to replace our main shopping streets with 20 storey buildings as a NIMBY. That misses a large chunk of the nuance in successful urban planning.
Sorry, have to take issue with your suggestion that we shouldn't invest in transit there. If you've been through Centretown, the Glebe and Old Ottawa South lately, you'd see that there is a ton of intensification happening in that corridor. When you look at the number of underdeveloped lots that still exist on or near Bank and the possibility of adding more housing at Lansdowne, there is all sorts of potential.
I'm not sure why you would argue against investing in better transit in areas that generate some of the highest transit ridership in the city (and not just commuter ridership). I would say that the failure to properly invest in urban transit is a big reason that OC ridership growth has been disappointing for years.
Lastly, I don't think that you can label someone who doesn't want to replace our main shopping streets with 20 storey buildings as a NIMBY. That misses a large chunk of the nuance in successful urban planning.
First not talking about Centertown this is about the glebe or at most OOS (South of the 417 north of rideau river).
As JOT pointed out, Dev is happening elsewhere, so why would a city increase its limited funds and Dev fees into an area that has little to no growth potential? compared to say Montreal rd or Carling where the need is far greater. At most at this density all the Glebe needs is bus lanes, the rest of the infrastructure has kept pace.
Secondly, If properly setback what difference does it make to the street level if its 4 to 20+ stories, and the sites as they are now are plenty deep enough to allow for more then 4 stories. Cities all over the world get along just fine with 6 to 8 story mainstreets. Ottawa already has its 4 story area, and its called byward market
Also, a hypothetical:
1) If Bank street got a subway, LRT, or BRT in the glebe would you still think 4 stories limit on the entire lot that face bank should still stand?
2) Exactly how far back must the 4 story height limit be kept to maintain the so called character/charm? and if a development was behind said line in an URBAN ward how high could they build? (cause I bet the lot depth meet the reasonable answer)
The Picture on the right: https://twitter.com/alexbozikovic/status/1468960766862577670 and others in that thread....
Well, as I mentioned in my post, I would strongly disagree with your assertion that there is no growth potential along Bank. Even in the 4-storey area (which to be clear is a total of about 8 blocks) there is plenty of room for growth and there is an equal number of blocks in the Glebe is zoned higher.
But I fundamentally disagree with your suggestion that we can only build transit in place where the most potential growth is. That’s how we ended up building rail into greenfields where transit-oriented suburbs are allegedly going to appear. Of course none have yet. Why, exactly, can’t we invest in transit where people actually live now?
And in terms of your suggestion that cities all over the world get by fine with 6-8 storey mainstreets, I’d be curious which cities have their major shopping streets at 8 stories (or higher as you seem to be suggesting). Certainly the shopping stretches of Ste. Catherine, St. Laurent or Yonge or Robson are not that high, except in a few spots. I’ll give you Fifth Avenue, but I’d say it’s an outlier. Even big, wide boulevards like the Champs-Élysées aren’t that high.
Human-scaled places are the most successful places for a reason. And believe it or not, cities can have more than one of those areas.
As for how far the limit should extend, I don’t think 20-storey buildings are necessary anywhere in the residential part of the Glebe or Old Ottawa South. There are plenty of spots for taller buildings along Isabella, along Bronson and near Lansdowne. Essentially just what the plan envisions. There’s no need to wreck street that works, and perhaps our best example of a 15-minute neighbourhood in a blind rush to build tall absolutely everywhere.
Mass transit requires density or lots of bus feeders. Bank Street has neither. “We want mass transit but we want to keep our two story (streetcar) suburban neighborhoods” is not a viable approach to urban planning. European cities often don’t have skyscrapers, but buildings in the city centre are typically 4-6+ throughout. There are few 2 story detached houses with backyards, whereas that is pretty much the entire bank corridor south of Laurier.