Pardon my lack of knowledge in following this thread. Why exactly can't we create a model that separates home/unit value from LAND value? Shouldn't SFH owners be able to profit massively in a scenario where land prices keep rising, but individual homes go down? Naturally, that requires more than one unit per lot, but if a sfh owner could redevelop their own lot into a tri/quadplex, they have every right to sell those units at market rate. They'd have enough money leftover to probably buy a new detached home at that point. I get this deals with zoning, for which I am more familiar with the issues of this idea, but I don't seem to understand why any political entity doesn't see the financial opportunity to actively incentivize rich homeowners to self-develop (densify!) their own lots for bank. It wouldn't solve the affordability crisis completely of course, but it would be a start, no?
This is presumably the premise behind upzoning neighbourhoods in general after all. If all sfh were to become, say, triplexes, they'd have tripled population density, increased affordability (theoretically) etc. And, implementation for this would need to actually acknowledge the typical issues of policy and nimbyism, but this discussion is very much about upper-level Government influence right now. To reiterate the premise, is there a gap in reasoning to suggest that property owners now have enough collateral from their own land that they could become mini-developers themselves? The incentive obviously is that if a quadplex is strictly rental for instance, the prior owners can continue holding that land as a landlord and reap the same if not more financial benefit. They could even live in a self-designed 'penthouse unit', give themselves access to the green space on the lot (if any) or whatever other incentive you could imagine for these 'landlords' to have a relatively unimpeded life (assuming ideally they don't just move away to another burb and further the issue).
This is meant to be a solution that appeases land/homeowners in the short term while slowly separating urban housing price/stock from the land it all sits upon. This would naturally foster lots of development, drive down home prices, and keep landowners happy. If there's anyone who sees obvious flaws in my logic here, I'd love to hear it!