NEW YORK | HDSN (418 11th Ave) | FT | 70 & 40 FLOORS


How old are you if this is one of the most fucked up things you've ever seen?

Old enough to know when something is absurd and ridiculous and arrogant for that matter. You signed up for this forum what 6 weeks ago and you are confronting people like you own the place? Tisk tisk.
 
If this were the standard setback design, many would complain that it was uninspired and boring. This simply reveals that no matter the design there will always be someone who doesn’t like it. There is no pleasing everyone, especially here.



We still don’t know which design will be chosen, but this would be perfectly fine. We’d be seeing complaints about whatever is chosen. This would be perfectly fibe for the Hudson Yards. You could even say needed.



172109829.Of2P2x80.7C060FA276FC489286C0534ED0ADA318.jpeg
 
We still don’t know which design will be chosen, but this would be perfectly fine. We’d be seeing complaints about whatever is chosen. This would be perfectly fibe for the Hudson Yards. You could even say needed.



172109829.Of2P2x80.7C060FA276FC489286C0534ED0ADA318.jpeg

I suspect that this will be selected, and I'll be elated. This is amazing. Only in New York! :cheers::cheers:
 
Old enough to know when something is absurd and ridiculous and arrogant for that matter. You signed up for this forum what 6 weeks ago and you are confronting people like you own the place? Tisk tisk.

OMG. Please take it to PM if y’all want to fight.
 
I'm curious if there are terraces on the eastern facade, and if that offsets the offsets a little. It's like the western facade is hollowed out. I would imagine there are terraces on the other side, but we haven't seen it.
 
I would like this one far more if the base and top had the same width and it narrowed in the middle, rather than starting out narrow and widening linearly.

It would instead be a concave arc of symmetrical setbacks and cantilevers
 
God I hate this building so much. Especially because it's so tall. I already do not love the design of CPT so if they build THIS too I think it'll really hinder the beauty of NYC's skyline
 
We still don’t know which design will be chosen, but this would be perfectly fine. We’d be seeing complaints about whatever is chosen. This would be perfectly fibe for the Hudson Yards. You could even say needed.



172109829.Of2P2x80.7C060FA276FC489286C0534ED0ADA318.jpeg

And I would add perfect for the site. :)
 
Maybe I'm in the minority but I kind of like it aside from the cantilevered angle, which is ugly.

Tower Fifth on the other hand is way worse IMO.

Am I correct in assuming this proposal is basically visionary and doesn't actually stand any real chance of being built?
 
Maybe I'm in the minority but I kind of like it aside from the cantilevered angle, which is ugly.

Tower Fifth on the other hand is way worse IMO.

Am I correct in assuming this proposal is basically visionary and doesn't actually stand any real chance of being built?

Tbh, Tower Fifth isn’t ugly to me since there’s nothing ugly about it. Besides, Tower Fifth looks good and dang futuristic. But they should probably rename it since we know it’s in the Fifth Avenue duh. Let’s see what Macklowe is going to say about this Affirmation Tower’s height. Gain it or lose it.
 
Maybe I'm in the minority but I kind of like it aside from the cantilevered angle, which is ugly.

You know, when I first saw this I was downright repulsed by it, but just now I looked at it again and found it only mildly ugly, so I might get used to it eventually:

Adjaye-towers.jpg
 
It would look great being worn by one of these guys, but actually built not so much...

_J4aeRI6gfWzsxS2mV0OEahOioxu3vIRFMHez8HHqKdkfhnymDB9CofF5PWXW-7o0pzePeROsN6oHrYfXkLxGaAJ25TReruq5JZR3aUAX2iU-z0zDeZatMu6anStNkf8uPTP5SxF-THlRg



They should update that with 175 Park, One Vanderbilt, Steinway (who could fit it?), Brooklyn Tower, 53W53, the Spiral, 30 Hudson, 270 Park (it would be invisible), and imagine Tower Fifth and this proposal included in the mix.
 
I can’t see this not being built. It seems to have a smallish office component, a huge hotel component, and perhaps some residential. Therefore, it doesn’t seem to be one of these enormous office towers that requires a large anchor commitment.
 


Back
Top