City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.
City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.
Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.
The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.
If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.![]()
I wonder about the population estimates for Caracas. We might never know.
In any case, it might be decades before anyone can make rough estimates. Caracas was probably the richest city in Latin America in the 1960's/1970's. Now it's likely much poorer than Bogota.
As we have the US Census numbers, here an update for the situation in the continent.
Largest Metropolitan Areas in Americas (2020)
--------------------- 2020 --- 10-year growth
Mexico City ----- 22.727.239 --- 9,0%
New York -------- 22.692.839 --- 6,2%
São Paulo ------- 22.020.009 --- 8,4%
Los Angeles ----- 18.644.680 --- 4,3%
Buenos Aires ---- 16.025.500 -- 11,5%
Rio de Janeiro -- 12.616.337 --- 6,7%
Lima ------------ 10.804.609 -- 17,5%
Bogotá ----------- 9.986.954 -- 14,5%
Chicago ---------- 9.618.502 --- 1,7%
San Francisco ---- 8.036.501 --- 8,4%
Toronto ---------- 7.950.441 -- 14,5%
Santiago --------- 7.912.746 -- 15,0%
Dallas ----------- 7.320.577 -- 19,9%
Houston ---------- 7.122.240 -- 20,3%
Philadelphia ----- 6.245.051 --- 4,7%
Miami ------------ 6.138.333 -- 10,3%
Boston ----------- 6.095.791 --- 8,3%
Atlanta ---------- 6.089.815 -- 15,2%
Washington ------- 5.937.417 -- 13,3%
Monterrey -------- 5.341.177 -- 26,4%
Detroit ---------- 5.325.319 --- 2,0%
Guadalajara ------ 5.268.642 -- 16,5%
Belo Horizonte --- 5.244.005 --- 9,9%
For the US and Mexico, 2020 Census numbers. For other countries, estimates as several had their census postponed or conduct on other periods.
Atlanta should surpass Boston, Miami, and Philly in the next census.
As we have the US Census numbers, here an update for the situation in the continent.
Largest Metropolitan Areas in Americas (2020)
--------------------- 2020 --- 10-year growth
Mexico City ----- 22.727.239 --- 9,0%
New York -------- 22.692.839 --- 6,2%
São Paulo ------- 22.020.009 --- 8,4%
Los Angeles ----- 18.644.680 --- 4,3%
Buenos Aires ---- 16.025.500 -- 11,5%
Rio de Janeiro -- 12.616.337 --- 6,7%
Lima ------------ 10.804.609 -- 17,5%
Bogotá ----------- 9.986.954 -- 14,5%
Chicago ---------- 9.618.502 --- 1,7%
San Francisco ---- 8.036.501 --- 8,4%
Toronto ---------- 7.950.441 -- 14,5%
Santiago --------- 7.912.746 -- 15,0%
Dallas ----------- 7.320.577 -- 19,9%
Houston ---------- 7.122.240 -- 20,3%
Philadelphia ----- 6.245.051 --- 4,7%
Miami ------------ 6.138.333 -- 10,3%
Boston ----------- 6.095.791 --- 8,3%
Atlanta ---------- 6.089.815 -- 15,2%
Washington ------- 5.937.417 -- 13,3%
Monterrey -------- 5.341.177 -- 26,4%
Detroit ---------- 5.325.319 --- 2,0%
Guadalajara ------ 5.268.642 -- 16,5%
Belo Horizonte --- 5.244.005 --- 9,9%
For the US and Mexico, 2020 Census numbers. For other countries, estimates as several had their census postponed or conduct on other periods.
A lot can happen in the decade to come. Hopefully the tri-state continues to grow strong. I think economic updates and housing will be big predictors. If the region remains strong, and housing keeps up, there could be the chance to make the predictions wrong (say 2030 estimates). As with other metros.
It'll be interesting to see what working from home/remote work will do to the nations population distribution. Possibly tech will be the catalyst that leads to sizable density in some of our burbs.
Wow, NY almost retook the throne of largest urban area in the western hemisphere?
--- San Francisco, Toronto, Santiago, Dallas and Houston all growing fast. For now. Chilean capital will start to deal with smaller growth as births plunged there. San Francisco and Toronto with high housing prices. And the Texans, well, they're the strongest bet to keep growing at a fast pace;
--- Seattle, Phoenix and Caracas are about to break the 5 million barrier. We have some on the continent 4 million people metro areas (Brasília, Recife, Porto Alegre, Montreal) but they're still far away from the 5 million mark.
The Mexican Big Three (Mexico City, Guadalajara, Monterrey) are now stereotyped as safest for middle class people, and rural areas are now stereotyped as lawless, with drug warlords controlling most public services. Not sure ether stereotype is rooted in reality, however.
So it's likely that middle class Mexicans have reversed their migration patterns from the 90's and 00's, when they were fleeing the biggest cities.
In absolute numbers, Toronto CMA was the fastest growing metro in Canada/US before the pandemic hit. Dallas/Houston absolute population growth started heading down and fell significantly below Toronto. It suggests that Toronto is the best bet to have the strongest growth in that grouping. 10 years is a long time but the most recent non-COVID data is all one can go by. You're correct to mention high real estate prices as a drag on population growth. Torontonians are de-camping to KW, London, and Halifax. Time will tell, I guess.
MONTREAL (4,576,312)
4,364,189 (Montreal) + 42,854 (Salaberry-de-Valleyfield) + 61,424 (Saint Hyacinthe) + 13,472 (Lachute) + 52,261 (Joliiette) + 42,112 (Sorel-Tracy)
Montreal could be above 5 million at the end of the next 10 year period, 2030. It sits in a fairly dense area with a large number of sizeable towns that increasingly behave like bedroom communities of Montreal. One of these CAs (Census Agglomerations) will be added to the Montreal CMA (Census Metropolitan Area) for the 2021 Census according to Statistics Canada. I can remember which one. The rest could easily get absorbed by the end of the decade. Above are population estimates of 5 notable CAs that sit close to the Montreal CMA. If they had been part of the Montreal CMA in 2020 it would have had a population of 4,151,965 in 2010 and 4,576,212 in 2020. If this area grows at the same rate that it did 2010-2020 (+424,347 or 10.22%) it would register 5,044,011 in 2030.
Montreal, arguably, sprawls more than any other Canadian metro. Montrealers seem to gravitate to these satellite towns in search of space. The numerous towns circling Montreal have a high likelihood of becoming growth centres for Montreal CMA and then absorbed by it. And there are others besides the 5 CAs I listed.
https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl...dYear=2020&referencePeriods=20100101,20200101
https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl...dYear=2020&referencePeriods=20100101,20200101
Is Puebla also a part of that group of safe cities?
TX is the second youngest state in the U.S. (only Mormon Utah is younger), and most of its growth is due to high birth rates from Mexican-Americans.What's the source for Dallas and Houston slowing down? US Census numbers came above Estimates for the most part. I wouldn't use US yearly estimates to make any conclusions about Dallas and Houston.
TX is the second youngest state in the U.S. (only Mormon Utah is younger), and most of its growth is due to high birth rates from Mexican-Americans.
Mexican immigration has been dropping, and Hispanic birth rates have been dropping. So it's likely that the growth rate slows. If you have a gigantic share of your population consisting of Hispanics of child-bearing age, that growth balloon will slightly deflate as that cohort ages.
TX is the second youngest state in the U.S. (only Mormon Utah is younger), and most of its growth is due to high birth rates from Mexican-Americans.
Mexican immigration has been dropping, and Hispanic birth rates have been dropping. So it's likely that the growth rate slows. If you have a gigantic share of your population consisting of Hispanics of child-bearing age, that growth balloon will slightly deflate as that cohort ages.
Hm interesting point. I wonder if Los Angeles' low rate of growth is is partly attributable to this, too.
What's the source for Dallas and Houston slowing down? US Census numbers came above Estimates for the most part. I wouldn't use US yearly estimates to make any conclusions about Dallas and Houston.
Dallas CSA (which would probably its MSA by 2030), added 1.314 million between 2010 and 2020 while Houston CSA added 1.212 million. Let's wait for Canadian numbers, but no estimate indicates Toronto (plus Hamilton, Oshawa and Guelph, definition I used) will add more people between 2011-2021. I would bet +1.0 million for the region.
About Montreal, let's wait for 2021 Census numbers. If they confirm those 4.5 million, 5 million is possible for 2031.
BTW, do Canadians expand their metro areas? Any chance of those small areas orbitting Montreal to be regarded as part of it, officially?