Aylmer
Still optimistic
In the future, it might actually be interesting to have a Toronto-Winnipeg route via Chicago. Between a future HFR West to Windsor, the improved Detroit-Chicago and Chicago-Minneapolis routes, you could already get from Toronto to Minneapolis in only 10 hours. At conventional speeds from there, you'd get to Winnipeg 7 hours from there. It's a total of 17h vs today's 35 hours.
Before I get read for railfanning, I'm obviously not saying every trip between the prairies and the corridor would be appropriate to pass this way or by train at all. Simply that leveraging the numerous rail upgrades happening on the route anyways would open up some interesting new possibilities and mobility options. As many forumers point out, it's difficult to justify investing in passenger infrastructure for the meagre number of long-haul passengers. Perhaps piggybacking on the improvements in short- and medium-distance routes is the best hope for long-distance services then. Like, it's hard to justify upgrades for a twice-per-week Canadian, or even a daily service. But if you've got some everyday medium-distance services between closer city pairs, and commuter/regional-type short-distance services, then it's easier to get investments in track improvements, dedicated corridors, and well-placed stations that can also be used by long-distance routes. The long distance routes aren't the main point, but a happy secondary effect.
The Toronto-Minneapolis improvements are already happening. Perhaps one day we start to see intra-Prairie routes as well (Regina-Saskatoon, Brandon-Winnipeg, Saskatoon-Battleford-Lloydminster-Edmonton, etc.). With upgrades in these two regions and a bit of stitching, you could get, say, Toronto-Edmonton from the current 61 hours down to 24. And by decreasing trip times and spreading out the fixed costs of the infrastructure over many more passengers on the short routes, VIA would have the ability to run more frequencies with cheaper tickets. It moves us towards a more robust intercity transportation network.
There likely won't be a time when everyone will opt to take a 24h train over a 3h flight, but that's not the point. The point of a robust mobility network is to have a suite of viable, dignified options to best suit a given trip or traveler. We're getting better at doing this for short-distance trips, with improved metropolitan and corridor transit and intercity options. I think that the next frontier will be doing the same for medium- and long-distance trips.
Before I get read for railfanning, I'm obviously not saying every trip between the prairies and the corridor would be appropriate to pass this way or by train at all. Simply that leveraging the numerous rail upgrades happening on the route anyways would open up some interesting new possibilities and mobility options. As many forumers point out, it's difficult to justify investing in passenger infrastructure for the meagre number of long-haul passengers. Perhaps piggybacking on the improvements in short- and medium-distance routes is the best hope for long-distance services then. Like, it's hard to justify upgrades for a twice-per-week Canadian, or even a daily service. But if you've got some everyday medium-distance services between closer city pairs, and commuter/regional-type short-distance services, then it's easier to get investments in track improvements, dedicated corridors, and well-placed stations that can also be used by long-distance routes. The long distance routes aren't the main point, but a happy secondary effect.
The Toronto-Minneapolis improvements are already happening. Perhaps one day we start to see intra-Prairie routes as well (Regina-Saskatoon, Brandon-Winnipeg, Saskatoon-Battleford-Lloydminster-Edmonton, etc.). With upgrades in these two regions and a bit of stitching, you could get, say, Toronto-Edmonton from the current 61 hours down to 24. And by decreasing trip times and spreading out the fixed costs of the infrastructure over many more passengers on the short routes, VIA would have the ability to run more frequencies with cheaper tickets. It moves us towards a more robust intercity transportation network.
There likely won't be a time when everyone will opt to take a 24h train over a 3h flight, but that's not the point. The point of a robust mobility network is to have a suite of viable, dignified options to best suit a given trip or traveler. We're getting better at doing this for short-distance trips, with improved metropolitan and corridor transit and intercity options. I think that the next frontier will be doing the same for medium- and long-distance trips.
Last edited:
