The point of HFR is to separate VIA trains from CP and CN ones. Sharing with GO would probably be OK.
According to the Canadian Rail Atlas GO owns the lines into Toronto, there's six tracks and room for more. Getting from those lines to the line to Peterborough (I think that's the Havelock Subdivision?) might be a little more challenging but harder things have been done. It might require bending over for CP/CN one last time, but then VIA will be free. Yes I am (more accurately, VIA) proposing building new stations, tunnels or flyovers - we don't know what form yet but that's where your $6-$12 billion goes. The money needs to be spent to get something that works.
Bi-modes are a shite compromise and would be a failure of policy.
And of course a big part of electrification is reduced maintenance costs, and reduced CO2 emissions. The corridor is the ideal place for electrification since a large proportion of the electricity comes from hydro and nuclear.
Both, electrical trains and internal combustion engine (ICE) cars were considered modern already 100 years ago, with the Deux-Montagnes line opening in 1923 as Canada's first (and until its demolition for the REM scam: only) electrified heavy rail line.I'm fairly excited that we're getting a 1980's (diesel) rail line in 2021 (+10 or more years)!
Woo hoo! We're so modern, we're bordering on groovy!
You can find the capital cost and travel time estimates in the two parts of deliverable 6 of the Ecotrain Study, but as we discussed last week, you may want to square the CPI adjustment factor to obtain more realistic cost values...I'm just honestly confused as to why they can't implement high speed rail, ala bullet train. It can't cost much more but only marginally shave off trip times.
To avoid exactly the kind of fragmentation which plagues international operations all across Europe (let Denmark's endless wisdom to electrify their national network at 25 kV@50Hz AC, which has become the leading global standard, but is unfortunately different to the 15 [email protected], which all its neighbors - from Finland to Switzerland and Austria - operate, be a warning!), there is no point to electrify any intercity routes without forcing the freight railroads to decide how they are going to electrify their transcontinental networks...If you are taking about reduced maintenance cost for locomotives and/or trainsets you are correct but there are higher costs related to the maintenance of ROW due to having to maintain electrical infrastructure compared to diesel, hydrogen or other alternative fuels which require no ROW infrastructure. Don't get me wrong, I am a proponent of electrifying the network but lets be realistic about the cost structure.
I was talking about Montreal not Toronto and yes access to Union Station in Toronto is enhanced by ownership of the ROW by GO Transit.
To avoid exactly the kind of fragmentation which plagues international operations all across Europe (let Denmark's endless wisdom to electrify their national network at 25 kV@50Hz AC, which has become the leading global standard, but is unfortunately different to the 15 [email protected], which all its neighbors - from Finland to Switzerland and Austria - operate, be a warning!), there is no point to electrify any intercity routes without forcing the freight railroads to decide how they are going to electrify their transcontinental networks...
If you are taking about reduced maintenance cost for locomotives and/or trainsets you are correct but there are higher costs related to the maintenance of ROW due to having to maintain electrical infrastructure compared to diesel, hydrogen or other alternative fuels which require no ROW infrastructure. Don't get me wrong, I am a proponent of electrifying the network but lets be realistic about the cost structure.
To avoid exactly the kind of fragmentation which plagues international operations all across Europe (let Denmark's endless wisdom to electrify their national network at 25 kV@50Hz AC, which has become the leading global standard, but is unfortunately different to the 15 [email protected], which all its neighbors - from Finland to Switzerland and Austria - operate, be a warning!), there is no point to electrify any intercity routes without forcing the freight railroads to decide how they are going to electrify their transcontinental networks...
I'm just honestly confused as to why they can't implement high speed rail, ala bullet train. It can't cost much more but only marginally shave off trip times.
Cost and politics. Fully Electric 300 kph HSR from Toronto to Quebec City would be at least $20 billion.
As it is, the opposition is already out complaining about the cost of this proposal. And this is apparently $6-12 billion.
Honestly, once all is said and done I bet the cost of HFR won't be that far off HSR and people will get the hindsightometer out and wonder why we didn't spend the money.
The most expensive part of HSR/HFR will be the approaches into the city. Unless they really cheap out with HFR, this will be similar in cost with either option. The cost difference in the countryside will be less. Trains will be more expensive for HSR, but you also need less of them and your staff costs are lower and ridership higher.
I can all but guarantee as well there will be mission creep. We'll spend a little here and there to grade separate a few more roads and chop off a few sharp corners, change the route to avoid some farms. Eventually your bare minimum HFR line looks (and costs) more like an HSR line.
But if this is what we need to do to get the tracks built, then it is what it is.
Honestly, once all is said and done I bet the cost of HFR won't be that far off HSR and people will get the hindsightometer out and wonder why we didn't spend the money.
The cost difference in the countryside will be less.
I can all but guarantee as well there will be mission creep. We'll spend a little here and there to grade separate a few more roads and chop off a few sharp corners, change the route to avoid some farms. Eventually your bare minimum HFR line looks (and costs) more like an HSR line.
But if this is what we need to do to get the tracks built, then it is what it is.
I think true 320 km/h HSR is starting to become what the battleship was after the end of the Second World War - technology that, while impressive on the surface and suggestive of power and might, is actually kind of a dodo bird given the new realities of how things work and the fact that less impressive, less costly new technologies can do the same job. Even European countries and China are scaling back on true HSR construction.
The problem with HSR is that you basically have to build a highly-engineered, grade-separated superstructure for almost its entire length. So it's like you're building a 500km long metro line.
...what is the marginal utility of getting between Toronto and Montreal in 2.5 hours versus 4 hours? Is it worth the added cost of constructing and operating a true HSR?
Or is it worth giving up the opportunity costs of lower-speed rail? For example, having places like Peterborough serve as bedroom communities for Toronto commuters is just as easily facilitated by HFR as it is with HSR. If Peterborough were a stop on an HSR line, it would lower the utility of people who want to travel between Toronto and Ottawa or Montreal quickly.
We'll know when the RFP is out in the Fall. The Siemens Chargers can be designed for bi-modal operation. Though, no idea if they have delivered any capable of that. I think they might just pass on exercising their options and just put a new fleet in the RFP. In theory, could just get battery electric trains for the last 10%.
The correct approach here isn't to talk about whether to build 200 kph or 300 kph service. It's to talk about what the target travel time should be and work back from there.
Aren't they already building the engines?
Ok, I want to do Toronto-Montreal in a hour......
To make thing worse, Radio Canada and La Presse have crazy ideas about bypassing Ottawa. So no idea what the real details are.
The correct approach here isn't to talk about whether to build 200 kph or 300 kph service. It's to talk about what the target travel time should be and work back from there.
A good comparison in my opinion for Toronto-Ottawa-Montreal is Madrid-Zaragoza-Barcelona. About the same distance. It's got non-stop service that takes 2.5 hrs. And non-express service that takes 3:10 hrs. I would argue that we need 3 hr express and 4 hrs all stop to be competitive. HFR from Toronto to Ottawa should show how effective rail can be at reducing air travel demand.
If HFR is very successful, an Ottawa bypass for Toronto-Montreal express trains via the CP Winchester subdivision would likely cut travel times by at least 30 minutes. This does not need to negatively impact service to Ottawa. This would be a natural future upgrade.
That would negate the very purpose of HFR: having a dedicated passenger rail corridor that VIA can control and ensure reliability on. They'd be back to where we are today. Only now trading CP for CN.