Add in the fact that they're having trouble renting units (if that's true) and we're getting pretty close to a market adjustment.
Apartment rents witnessed the slowest annual rise in 17 months – a 3% increase in one year, reaching $1,474, according to a report from RENTCafé. The national average rent ended 2019 by slipping $1 compared to November, but the rent increases are still an average of $43 more compared with one year ago.
Here are the highlights for rent increases in Metro Phoenix:
• Phoenix ended the year charging $1,123 in average rent, after a $98 increase over one year, or 9.6%. This is the largest increase from among the US renter mega-hubs.
• Even higher increases were registered in Avondale, 11.2%, and Mesa, 9.9%. Avondale rents added $122 since the end of 2018, reaching $1,215. Meanwhile, Mesa average rents went up $99, to $1,094.
• Scottsdale charges the most expensive rents, $1,560 on average. They went up $91 compared to one year ago.
• The cheapest rents are in Glendale. Here the average reached $1,026, after adding $79 since the end of 2018.
• The slowest rent increase was registered in Goodyear, as rents here added $62 in one year, reaching $1,252.
Nationally, apartments were renting for $1,474 on average at the end of 2019, after the slowest annual rise in the past 17 months, 3%. Furthermore, rates displayed a slower yearly growth at the end of 2019 than in the previous year, when they went up by 3.2% according to apartment rent data from Yardi Matrix. In net dollars, renters are now paying $43 more per month for an apartment than they did in December 2018. By comparison, in the previous year, they saw a $45 rent hike compared to 2017.
The winddown comes after a decade of thriving apartment construction in which over 2.4M units were built across the nation. The U.S. economy remains strong while developers continue to deliver apartments in multiple locations. The apartment industry has made great strides since the great recession of 2008 and will remain a strong economic engine as we enter the new decade, says Doug Ressler, Manager of Business Intelligence at Yardi Matrix.
RENTCafé’s year-end rent report can be accessed here: https://www.rentcafe.com/blog/rental-market/apartment-rent-report/year-end-rent-report-2019/.
I made an argument to you all quite some time ago that the occupancy numbers are false for a lot of these buildings because they've taken many units out of inventory to use as short term rentals.
That's now appearing to be a supported argument.
Add in the fact that they're having trouble renting units (if that's true) and we're getting pretty close to a market adjustment.
Interesting side note: The most expensive apartment building I have in my portfolio is getting me about $1,100 for two bedrooms. It's in Garfield. I haven't had a turnover in that building of 4 units in over 3 years. If anything I love the high rent prices. A guy like me who has a building without all the superfluous amenities can offer a reasonable price and none of my tenants can afford to move because everything else downtown is double the price!
Isn't Aspirant/Empire Group behind the potential Astra?
How many people really understand the way the apartment business works, though?
Developers don't care about anything other than getting the pro-forma in order enough to flip the building. As long as lenders see the ability to sell the building in 8-12 months after completion they'll keep lending money. Rent rolls and occupancy numbers play a factor there but the bet is more on the "will a canadian REIT buy this finished product?"
Building defects are not a new phenomenon being uncovered by The Stewart. I was in the trenches at Landmark when we had that legal battle. It's the same story. The homeowners sued the contractor there and won a large, but not large enough, sum of money.
I made an argument to you all quite some time ago that the occupancy numbers are false for a lot of these buildings because they've taken many units out of inventory to use as short term rentals.
That's now appearing to be a supported argument.
Add in the fact that they're having trouble renting units (if that's true) and we're getting pretty close to a market adjustment.
Interesting side note: The most expensive apartment building I have in my portfolio is getting me about $1,100 for two bedrooms. It's in Garfield. I haven't had a turnover in that building of 4 units in over 3 years. If anything I love the high rent prices. A guy like me who has a building without all the superfluous amenities can offer a reasonable price and none of my tenants can afford to move because everything else downtown is double the price!
I haven't seen anyone verify the 50% occupancy claims stated in the article. More than likely it is higher.
Many apartment complexes, including ones without an occupancy problem, are renting out units to companies like Sonder and Wanderjaunt. Why wouldn't a developer want a 25% increase in revenue from 10% of their units?
1 does not make a trend, especially 1 where the word on the street is that the complex is poorly managed.
Verify the low occupancy numbers at The Stewart and corroborate those with The Link and Block 23 and then we can talk about a market correction.
75% is not good for an established property, but I'm not sure I would consider Stewart "established" at this point. Come back to me in six months.
If we get the feeling that 75% is the prevailing occupancy rate downtown then that's worrisome. Again, the inexpensive stuff rents instantly and people don't move out of it. There's a very high demand for a shrinking inventory. The question in my mind is how these "luxury" buildings will fare. Like I was saying at the beginning too much of one thing will result in hard times, not for the developers but for the guys left holding the bag.
75% is not good for an established property, but I'm not sure I would consider Stewart "established" at this point. Come back to me in six months.
If we get the feeling that 75% is the prevailing occupancy rate downtown then that's worrisome. Again, the inexpensive stuff rents instantly and people don't move out of it. There's a very high demand for a shrinking inventory. The question in my mind is how these "luxury" buildings will fare. Like I was saying at the beginning too much of one thing will result in hard times, not for the developers but for the guys left holding the bag.
I agree. These buildings should be 90%+ occupied but if the Stewart is at 75%, I could pretty easily write off the 15% deviation to poor management.
I think the downtown Phoenix luxury apartment market is one to monitor.
Will be interesting to see how things progress with the influx of the 2,000? or so new units coming in the next year and a half.
In the 1980's it resulted in management companies giving away the farm to get people to sign leases. There was one point when getting a free cruise was possible. I'm not sure we'll get that far since the city is growing so rapidly but I think it's extremely reasonable to expect some adjustments.
The main issue for me, and I've been saying it for a long time, is these buildings are all the same product. There may be a huge influx of new residents but developers are operating as if they are all in the same tax bracket. Not a good recipe for long term success - but again, developers only need to make it work long enough to get the pro forma in order.
New Retail, Residential and Offices at CityScape
CityScape’s Block 23 mixed-use development welcomed Fry’s Grocery last year – but there’s even more to come for the development in 2020. WeWork just opened at Block 23 in early January 2020, with other office tenants and a 16-story residential development, The Ryan, leasing by the end of April. We can also look forward to a Blanco Tacos & Tequila in early summer on the ground floor of The Ryan.
The corner of Central Avenue and Washington Street will be adding Pigtails, a speak-easy style craft cocktail bar from the owners of The Whining Pig, in early February. Look for a Dog Haus Biergarten location opening next door to Pigtails in early March – and a Nekter Juice Bar following later in the spring.
Central Station groundbreaking – Summer
The Central Station development reimagines downtown’s bus transit center at Central Avenue and Van Buren Street. Breaking ground this summer, the project will have 152 hotel rooms, 25 floors of apartment units, office and retail space.
There will also be a student housing tower that is set to open by fall 2023. The remainder of the project will be completed by the end of 2023. (rendering below also looks different from before i think?)
![]()
Apparently, Stewart has mad issues and also having problems renting out the units to the point that 2 floors have been converted to Airbnb units. I am also surprised to read it's its so easy to walk into the building without having to enter a code or use a key. Link has a code box installed and most places downtown have some kind of security or another.
I hope Aspire doesn't have these same problems or Aspirant/Empire is going to run into reputation issues down the road for providing shoddy buildings.
https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/the-stewart-downtown-phoenix-luxury-high-rise-has-problems-11429237
A couple of updates here I haven't heard of before along with some anticipated opening dates of some known retail...
https://dtphx.org/2020/01/21/15-downtown-phoenix-things-to-look-forward-to-in-2020/
No this has been the render for a while, but this is a nice big version.
The heights of the buildgins are off as the Central and Van Buren tower is supposed to be 30-35 floors I thought, with the building fronting 1st ave being 25 but the rendering has like a 50 story south tower and a 12 story west tower.
Anyone who thinks there's a homeless problem here needs to spend about 3 days walking around San Francisco.