pj3000
New member
We're all very well aware that NYC and Chicago are way beyond everyone else when it comes to US skylines. And of course, NYC is far above Chicago and Chicago is far above all the rest.
But I prefer not to define tiers by individual ranking because you then you really need to apply the same methodology for the rest of the cities in the nation. Meaning, you can't just say "NYC, then Chicago, then all the rest" or something akin to that, because that's just not a valid analysis of the set. There would be others who stood in their own tier too... who knows? Maybe Tulsa is also all by itself somewhere down on the list when you really break down the numbers... or maybe some tiers have 2 cities in them, some have 3, and some have 8 or 12... it fucks everything up and you end up not really having tiers, because the tiers are then defined by the data points, rather than being the standard structure that the data points must fit into.
There are so many ways we could define tiers... total height groupings, # of buildings over 150m, over 200m, over 300m, over 400m, total height of buildings taller than 150m, total height of buildings taller than 200m, etc. etc... it could go on and on and on. And it might be interesting to do... and we'd see that NYC and Chicago would still come out on top... but for simplicity, I keep tiers easy.
To me, tiers are defined steps with equal rise separating them. I keep it simple:
Tier 1 = 1-10 tallest skylines
Tier 2 = 11-20 tallest skylines
Tier 3 = 21-30 tallest skylines
Tier 4 = "
Tier 5 = "
And then within that structure, you can apply whatever you want to define as "tallest". Maybe it's the standard, "number of buildings 150m+, with total combined height of those buildings determining order in a tie". Or maybe it's a different definition for tallest... you can do whatever quantitative analysis you want to... go nuts... but you still gotta have a standard structure that cities fit into, not tiers fitting to the cities.
That's why I said earlier that Houston and Dallas could be considered Tier 1 skyline cities.
And there's no such thing as half tiers or fitting into tiers because of a skyline's enhancement due to mountains, or coastline, or rivers, or walkability, or street-level feel, or pizza.
But I prefer not to define tiers by individual ranking because you then you really need to apply the same methodology for the rest of the cities in the nation. Meaning, you can't just say "NYC, then Chicago, then all the rest" or something akin to that, because that's just not a valid analysis of the set. There would be others who stood in their own tier too... who knows? Maybe Tulsa is also all by itself somewhere down on the list when you really break down the numbers... or maybe some tiers have 2 cities in them, some have 3, and some have 8 or 12... it fucks everything up and you end up not really having tiers, because the tiers are then defined by the data points, rather than being the standard structure that the data points must fit into.
There are so many ways we could define tiers... total height groupings, # of buildings over 150m, over 200m, over 300m, over 400m, total height of buildings taller than 150m, total height of buildings taller than 200m, etc. etc... it could go on and on and on. And it might be interesting to do... and we'd see that NYC and Chicago would still come out on top... but for simplicity, I keep tiers easy.
To me, tiers are defined steps with equal rise separating them. I keep it simple:
Tier 1 = 1-10 tallest skylines
Tier 2 = 11-20 tallest skylines
Tier 3 = 21-30 tallest skylines
Tier 4 = "
Tier 5 = "
And then within that structure, you can apply whatever you want to define as "tallest". Maybe it's the standard, "number of buildings 150m+, with total combined height of those buildings determining order in a tie". Or maybe it's a different definition for tallest... you can do whatever quantitative analysis you want to... go nuts... but you still gotta have a standard structure that cities fit into, not tiers fitting to the cities.
That's why I said earlier that Houston and Dallas could be considered Tier 1 skyline cities.
And there's no such thing as half tiers or fitting into tiers because of a skyline's enhancement due to mountains, or coastline, or rivers, or walkability, or street-level feel, or pizza.