The North One
Active member
This thing is too beautiful and too perfect, it needs to be built yesterday.
This thing is too beautiful and too perfect, it needs to be built yesterday.
Ugh, don't rub it in.:haha:
It seems like the only chance left for a Chicago supertall (other than Vista) in the near future. (Assuming 400LSD gets downsized without the hotel)
Unless of course something we don't know of pops up.
Nosir, it hasn't even filed its PD yet. (Though in the 42nd that typically doesn't happen until after Reilly is satisfied/greased up.)Has this (specifically the tower, not the renovation of the existing buildings) been approved by the Planning Commission?
Nosir, it hasn't even filed its PD yet. (Though in the 42nd that typically doesn't happen until after Reilly is satisfied/greased up.)
It would be interesting if they did make it shorter because why hire AS+GG if you're in the end just gonna trim it down?
I guess its all part of the business though
It is bizarre. I'm not sure why they would want everyone think they're building a 400+ meter building, pay money for the design (I assume they did?) and then back out.
Beyond many words, we have some news about the project?
Perhaps they didn't get the positive public feedback on their design they hoped for?
Hm, could be. Although I'm not sure what they found wrong with it. :shrug:
If you go back to the beginning of the thread for this project you can see a mixed bag of opinions. My core personal issue is that if it is going to pair with the Tribune Tower then it should do a better job with a more traditional stylistic approach. Others on this board claim it does pair with the Tribune Tower and other surrounding towers in more subtle modern ways, though I'm skeptical that these claims are true. Also the building has a general semblance to a lot of the tall buildings that have gone up in China in recent years. New York has several supertalls that don't look like Chinese buildings and I'd prefer we'd do the same.
It is impossible to build anything in a “traditional style” today. The skills and labor don’t exist, nor will they spend sufficiently on materials, nor will the methods be right. So what you will get is some god awful post-modernism. It’s best not to even try.
This is basically semantics. Ok, so the labor and skills “exist”, but they’re in such short supply as to make this uneconomical. You’d basically need to fly people over from Europe whose normal job is working on historical restorations. And I don’t think the price per square foot in Chicago would justify the cost, even if there was interest. Maybe in Manhattan.Just to clarify before LVDW beats me to it:
The skills and labor DO exist and the methods may or may not be the same, but they exist in such a manner to create a totally satisfying and true 'traditional' example if so desired...
You are right that it is the high cost of doing so that is keeping projects like OBP from using limestone, bronze, more traditional detailing, etc. and that is really the only reason by far and away why we don't see more traditionally detailed and built 'traditional' examples... (way behind cost being the number one reason, is a lack of desire in general for historic vocabulary followed by a lack of skill and training among architects to produce those designs properly)...
^ Did this dude just call Park Tower crap? Another horrible take by Anglophile troll that is 10023