So, a prof from the University of Michigan says the existing arena is "economically obsolete".
https://thestarphoenix.com/news/local-news/take-aways-from-saskatoons-arena-convention-centre-study
SaskTel Centre’s chief executive officer Will Lofdahl says we want to be competitive. Concerts are becoming more elaborate, exposing further limitations. The roof and trusses are too low etc etc etc..
https://thestarphoenix.com/news/local-news/aging-sasktel-centre-at-a-crossroads
So the push is on to spend an extra $250million and build new. As much as I would like an arena downtown, my question is this: If the current arena was built downtown (which would have been in the city yards) would there be any discussion about replacing it? If the answer is no, then get on with the renovations.
As far as I can tell, most of the shortcomings can be solved with the exception of the height of the roof and the location. And quite frankly I doubt we lose many events (Will Lofdahl please name just one) because of the roof.
So, as I see it we (the taxpayers) are been asked to spend $250million for a different location. Again, as much as I would love to see an arena downtown I struggle with the cost. I really see one question: Do you want to spend $250million to relocate the arena downtown. I'm sorry for those who want it but my answer right now is a resounding NO because I can not justify the cost just because of the current location is not ideal. You have your work cut out to convince me otherwise.
The decision in the 80s to put in where it is is costing us today because no, we wouldn't be having this discussion on replacing a downtown arena. We would be renovating it and the investment would be beneficial. Even now, what point is there in renovating an arena that is still on the edge of the city (30 years later to boot) with nothing around it?
Could've saved 100 million dollars today if the right decision had been made then.