Winnipeg | Everything Bicycles


Mpls is one of the most bike-friendly cities in the US. Yes our road network is poorly planned and forces traffic downtown. So what I don't understand is, instead of using your time and energy to push for improvements to traffic arteries and create an inner ring road, you spend it all having hissy fits about bikes. We had a crappy road network long before there were any bike lanes, a handful of bike lanes here and there is not going to make any difference. The peanuts we spend on bikes every year would have virtually no impact if it were redirected into the road budget. It's practically a rounding error. If you want better roads, fine, then focus your energy on that instead of yelling at guys on bikes.

This is one of the key points for me. It's also a key point that is often overlooked (whether on purpose or not) in the Portage & Main debate. Just because something "is not a priority" according to some people, doesn't mean it can't happen. That logic means that we as a city can and should only do 1 thing at a time. It's insane.
 
Mpls is one of the most bike-friendly cities in the US. Yes our road network is poorly planned and forces traffic downtown. So what I don't understand is, instead of using your time and energy to push for improvements to traffic arteries and create an inner ring road, you spend it all having hissy fits about bikes. We had a crappy road network long before there were any bike lanes, a handful of bike lanes here and there is not going to make any difference. The peanuts we spend on bikes every year would have virtually no impact if it were redirected into the road budget. It's practically a rounding error. If you want better roads, fine, then focus your energy on that instead of yelling at guys on bikes.

Disagree, society and tax dollars should be for the common good not spent frivolously on entitled groups. If you are outlying this amount of capital for only .01 % of the population that actively cycle and closing vehicle lanes is this really the best use of resources? Common sense would say no on many levels except in Skyscraper Page forums.
 
Disagree, society and tax dollars should be for the common good not spent frivolously on entitled groups. If you are outlying this amount of capital for only .01 % of the population that actively cycle and closing vehicle lanes is this really the best use of resources? Common sense would say no on many levels except in Skyscraper Page forums.

You make it sound like fortunes are spent on building cycling infrastructure. How big is the city's budget for AT infrastructure? I'd be surprised if it was even 1% of what gets spent on roads and transit each year.
 
Disagree, society and tax dollars should be for the common good not spent frivolously on entitled groups. If you are outlying this amount of capital for only .01 % of the population that actively cycle and closing vehicle lanes is this really the best use of resources? Common sense would say no on many levels except in Skyscraper Page forums.

Sorry to break this to you, but encouraging cycling over cars is for the common good.
 
rr meant for the common good of drivers.

The City budgeted $4.7m in 2017 and has $5.4m budgeted for each of the next 5 years on AT infrastructure. Capital spending is hovering around $360M each year (last year was actually $432m). So we're at about 1.5% of the capital budget on AT, which is walking too, not just cycling.

I'm pretty sure 100% of people walk. So that's pretty good value. I'm also sure more than 1.5% of people cycle.

Source: https://www.winnipeg.ca/finance/files/2018AdoptedCapitalBudget_Volume3.pdf
 
^ So realistically, once you part out the cycling-specific infrastructure (bike lanes, etc.) it'll be under 1%.

So remind me what all the fuss is about again?
 
rr meant for the common good of drivers.

The City budgeted $4.7m in 2017 and has $5.4m budgeted for each of the next 5 years on AT infrastructure. Capital spending is hovering around $360M each year (last year was actually $432m). So we're at about 1.5% of the capital budget on AT, which is walking too, not just cycling.

I'm pretty sure 100% of people walk. So that's pretty good value. I'm also sure more than 1.5% of people cycle.

Source: https://www.winnipeg.ca/finance/files/2018AdoptedCapitalBudget_Volume3.pdf

I have no problem with AT infrastructure, people use it year round and around the clock myself included. Hacked in bike lanes get used by very few for a couple hours of the day. Add up the real cost of the roadways these designated bike lanes are hacked into and not just the paint and curbs! Obviously more than 1.5% of the population cycle, but what is the real number that cycle commute on dedicated bike lanes, is it .01% or more like .001% obviously our climate dictates otherwise which furthers my argument against hacked in bike lanes!
 
Disagree, society and tax dollars should be for the common good not spent frivolously on entitled groups. If you are outlying this amount of capital for only .01 % of the population that actively cycle and closing vehicle lanes is this really the best use of resources? Common sense would say no on many levels except in Skyscraper Page forums.

I'd like to know where you got the number 0.01% of the population. It's already been established that's simply not factual. If you want to have a debate I'm all ears but if you're going to just continue to make stuff up like a child I have better things to do. The percentage of people who cycle exceeds the percentage of our budget given to cycling, meaning cyclists get less than their fair share. That's simply a fact. You're obviously not a numbers person but at least make an effort.
 
Last edited:
This survey from CAA (car lobby group) and Bike Winnipeg (bike lobby group) found 21% bike daily or a few times a week *for transportation* not just for recreation/pleasure.

http://bikewinnipeg.ca/2018/07/24/c...aa-bike-winnipeg-survey/#sthash.Sq6TCjAV.dpbs

This national poll found many Winnipeggers want bike lanes:

“Two-thirds of Winnipeg respondents said there were too few separated lanes (compared to 46 per cent of total respondents), while 76 per cent called the lanes "a good idea" (second only to Montreal’s 80 per cent).”

https://www.winnipegfreepress.com/local/residents-want-more-bike-lanes-survey-486785171.html
 
I'd like to know where you got the number 0.01% of the population. It's already been established that's simply not factual. If you want to have a debate I'm all ears but if you're going to just continue to make stuff up like a child I have better things to do. The percentage of people who cycle exceeds the percentage of our budget given to cycling, meaning cyclists get less than their fair share. That's simply a fact. You're obviously not a numbers person but at least make an effort.
Out of his butt perhaps??
 
I have no problem with AT infrastructure, people use it year round and around the clock myself included. Hacked in bike lanes get used by very few for a couple hours of the day. Add up the real cost of the roadways these designated bike lanes are hacked into and not just the paint and curbs! Obviously more than 1.5% of the population cycle, but what is the real number that cycle commute on dedicated bike lanes, is it .01% or more like .001% obviously our climate dictates otherwise which furthers my argument against hacked in bike lanes!

According to the 2016 census, 1.7% of the population use cycling as their main mode of transportation to work. So you are only off by 17000%.
 
There is no argument other than "you tuk 'r lanes!"

Despite the crude characterization of those who oppose losing travel lanes as slack-jawed yokels, I agree that more people seemed concerned with loss of lanes than cost.

I don't think generally there's as much concern over the 1% of spending going to AT; I think it's more the perception that they just lost 33% or 50% of the road capacity on a road they drive regularly.
 
Despite the crude characterization of those who oppose losing travel lanes as slack-jawed yokels, I agree that more people seemed concerned with loss of lanes than cost.

I don't think generally there's as much concern over the 1% of spending going to AT; I think it's more the perception that they just lost 33% or 50% of the road capacity on a road they drive regularly.

It's not just the 1% spent on curbs and paint for the dedicated bike lanes, the true cost is the expense of the road, if you have three lanes of roadway and one is hacked out for a bike lane the real cost is much higher, more like 33.3% of what the actual road cost is.
 


Back
Top