SingerCity
Active member
Given low demand levels and the corridor I bet automated people mover. Smaller stations helps to save big $ when they are all grade separated.
Given low demand levels and the corridor I bet automated people mover. Smaller stations helps to save big $ when they are all grade separated.
No operators is a plus, fair enough. Would those cost savings exceed the cost of building a guideway, buying and maintaining new vehicles vs building a grade separated road and running buses though?
I'm normally all for building rail vs buses. But, IMO, a people mover is even more rinky dink than a bus while offering little if any benefit.
nothing rinky-dink about building a maglev link from YYC right to downtown..
could be proof of concept / phase 0 of AB HSR.. and I think it would get a lot more use than an automated shuttle to the nearest LRT stop
and with a under 5 minute travel time from core to terminal, Calgary would essentially have a downtown airport! :notacrook:
nothing rinky-dink about building a maglev link from YYC right to downtown..
could be proof of concept / phase 0 of AB HSR.. and I think it would get a lot more use than an automated shuttle to the nearest LRT stop
and with a under 5 minute travel time from core to terminal, Calgary would essentially have a downtown airport! :notacrook:
Not going to happen. If Maglev was going to happen anywhere, it would have happened in China - and even here, they decided the Maglev was a bad idea after only building the white elephant that is the Shanghai Transrapid. If China, which has probably spent more money in the last decade on infrastructure than the rest of the world combined, decided not to go with Maglev, it's very unlikely to happen anywhere else either.
![]()
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/apr/21/japans-maglev-train-notches-up-new-world-speed-record-in-test-run
![]()
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ch%C5%AB%C5%8D_Shinkansen
It's totally understandable for China to have gone with more traditional HSR given the enormous network they were power building, and the QC problems along the way..
That said, my recent experiences on the HSR network there were great (far better than the airports!)
I have no doubt that a maglev line will happen at some point in China's future :yes:
Great. Who's paying?
I'll believe it when I see it in operation. There were big plans for Maglev here in China too - it was originally planned to extend all the way to Shanghai's other airport (Hongqiao) and all the way to Hangzhou prior to the 2010 Expo in Shanghai, but public protests and concerns about costs relative to traditional HSR prevented it from ever expanding beyond the short little line that was actually built (which predates the Chinese HSR system by several years, BTW - the Shanghai Transrapid opened in 2003, whereas the first true HSR line in China, the Beijing-Tianjin line, opened just prior to the Beijing Olympics in 2008).
Yeah, being an early adopter can definitely give one some hesitations about going further.. and for a big meshed network with lots of switch points, building out a widespread traditional HSR network first absolutely made sense.
I think maglev is a better fit for a simple linear route, like Cal-Edm or NE US. no complicated moving parts, just back and forth
apparently costs have dropped significantly in recent years too. the Japan project is costing ~$175m/km (USD), and that includes a lot of tunneling
meanwhile.. Calgary's PH1 Green line is estimated to be ~$230m/km (CAD)
If a maglev line came into the core elevated, might even be cheaper?
Only thing that comes to my mind is the monorail from the simpsons! Pretty sure that may have been Leonard Nimoys first episode. It didn’t end well.
Gonna cross post this on a few forums, some comments on a Toronto area forum compared the C-Train to GO transit in many ways and it does seem to be a somewhat apt comparison:
https://urbantoronto.ca/forum/threa...cluding-extensions.4952/page-826#post-1361622
How do people think we can improve the number of people using the C-Train outside of commuting? TOD, off-peak discount etc?