Agree with everything you're saying but 'WhipperSnapper' is an old boys club type. He's stubbornly stuck in his ways and intolerant of things being done differently than how he's used to. There's his way and the wrong way. He roundly ridiculed the suggestion that highrises would one day line Yonge Street from the traditional CBD to Yorkville. It's now unfolding exactly that way but he'll never admit that he was wrong.
Btw, lots of people in Toronto have criticized this proposal for not having residential. I'd be shocked if it progressed without residential regardless of how loudly some insist that they're right. Mixed use has been standard practice for many years already.![]()
Ah, that makes sense now.
The Bloomberg article describes the East Harbour development in Toronto as 12,000,000 sq ft of office/retail over 60 acres. But no residential space. Sixty acres!?! For perspective, 60 acres is about 55 football fields or about 15 or so NYC blocks. That's a sizable area for any city to be dedicated towards a single-use.
I can only think of lower Manhattan pre 9/11. It was a ghost town after all the office workers went home. There has since been a number of new residential developments, including some office conversions to residential. It's been nothing but good for the area and it's much more lively at all hours. This positive changes in the neighborhood has also made it more attractive to commercial landlords as they compete against other commercial hot spots in Hudson Yards and Midtown East.
I'm amazed how 12,000,000 sqft of office is seen as good, but throw in the potential for some residential units to compliment the 50,000 workers and that's seen as bad, risks becoming a bedroom community, and eats up "employment lands." Just because that's what zoning says it should be.