fypif skydome can't happen, commonwealth is a perfectly acceptable fallback.
fypif skydome can't happen, commonwealth is a perfectly acceptable fallback.
For the record I think a temporarily expanded BMO could work if FIFA is OK with having a bunch of temp seats, but the issue to me is why would you want to if you could have access to Skydome instead?
That said, I don't care that much either way... it's not like I'm writing to my MP over this issue. I'm sure Toronto could manage just fine even with BMO.
^you don't think that Edmonton/Commonwealth will be thrown into this mix?
The TFC people are saying that BMO is the best soccer specific stadium in the country. A few points on that, one, is it the best in a race of what, two horses (Saputo)? Is BMO actually now still classified as soccer specific, whatever that means.
It's quite simple. The stands were designed and are still designed around a soccer pitch; not baseball or football.
It's much easier to expand BMO to 40,000 and harmonize the exterior to make it look prettier and impressive for the 1 minute of airtime.
For the record I think a temporarily expanded BMO could work if FIFA is OK with having a bunch of temp seats
Why wouldn't they be ok with it?
They were OK with them in Brazil in 2014
Of course it isn't soccer specific that's the whole joke of it. Again why would FIFA care whether it was soccer first or last. No one seems to want to comment about how, AFAIK, none of the American stadiums will be soccer specific.Technically speaking, BMO field is no longer soccer specific. The field has been extended to accommodate the CFL, meaning a portion of the stands are too far from the pitch. None of this matters for FIFA of course, it is still a stadium designed for soccer first and then football.
Why, when Montreal needs and will get sooner or later an upgrade, a good excuse for federal money.In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if Canada ends up with only 2 host cities. They would be Vancouver and Toronto, in all likelihood.
Why, when Montreal needs and will get sooner or later an upgrade, a good excuse for federal money.
Also politically, I can't see Montreal getting left out, and five games for two cities is too much not to farm out a little bit and show some of the rest of the country to the world.
They're not going to have a team train in Montreal and play in Toronto or elsewhere. Nobody outside of the GTA would care if Toronto was left out. They weren't in the WWC and the sky didn't fall.Maybe Vancouver and Montreal. But i dont think Canada or FIFA can discard Toronto and BMO Field. And there has to be a Western city as a host as well. In the event there are only 2 host cities chosen for Canada, Vancouver is a guarantee, and then it has to be Toronto. Politics will get a back seat for this one, AFAIC.
Montreal will get a team or two based there for training. Saputo Stadium and Centre Nutrilait are ideal for this.
Anything is possible however.
They're not going to have a team train in Montreal and play in Toronto or elsewhere. Nobody outside of the GTA would care if Toronto was left out. They weren't in the WWC and the sky didn't fall.
You're saying politics will take a back seat but we need Toronto and a team from the west? In the entire history of our country Quebec is the ultimate political mover and shaker.
Fair enough point. I don't see why people have reservations about a stadium's size when we have nine years to add 10K seats to a stadium which has been temporarily expanded to that size before. The tournament isn't being held tomorrow, saying it won't work because of its size today seems short-sighted.Skydome is the better option in my opinion but I have no delusions about any perfect venues. I just think the problems of Skydome (turf, Jays) don't outweigh the problems of BMO (size, amenities, location). If Skydome can't happen, BMO is a perfectly acceptable fallback.
Adding 10k seats to BMO is gonna be free?
THF isn't a potential stadium for selection so i'm not exactly sure why you're bringing it up.Boy, are the Americans ever gonna look Mickey Mouse judging by the horror of THF here but then again their fields are shorter. But they`re still not a SSS as vital as that has to be.
Ridiculous line of thinking. It's Canada's largest city and arguably its best city for soccer. It has two viable options for hosting so neglecting to choose either of them would have to take a pretty impressive set of circumstances.Nobody outside of the GTA would care if Toronto was left out.
No one seems to want to comment about how, AFAIK, none of the American stadiums will be soccer specific.
How many games have TFC sold out? Permanently adding more seats is going to hurt ticket scarcityAdding 10K seats to BMO serves a feasible purpose beyond 2026 for both CSA and for TFC/events at BMO.
It was to show the dimensions of a soccer field within a football field had you have looked at the photo.THF isn't a potential stadium for selection so i'm not exactly sure why you're bringing it up.
Do you honestly think anyone outside the GTA would go up in arms if they selected Edmonton over Toronto, or chose Montreal or Vancouver over Toronto, seriously?Ridiculous line of thinking. It's Canada's largest city and arguably its best city for soccer. It has two viable options for hosting so neglecting to choose either of them would have to take a pretty impressive set of circumstances.
Then why would we choose a stadium in Toronto that seats 22k less?The US has a plethora of football stadiums to choose from that go above and beyond what is required to host WC matches. Why would the US select SSS in Columbus, Kansas City, or Portland (all too small to host) when they can select 80K NFL stadiums in major markets instead?
How many games have TFC sold out? Permanently adding more seats is going to hurt ticket scarcity
Ridiculous line of thinking. It's Canada's largest city and arguably its best city for soccer. It has two viable options for hosting so neglecting to choose either of them would have to take a pretty impressive set of circumstances.
.
Glad we can agree on something.Guys - let's just forget about BMO as a World Cup venue. The SSP Canada page has spoken. It's gonna be embarrassing.
Well that is about the same amount of bullshit as your oft mentioned trolling Canadian stadiums are crap routine.FIFA has a ranking of elite options to crap options that just meet the minimum requirements. I don't think Canada has more than 5 stadiums that would even get any sort of ranking, just because you can plop Ina soccer pitch does not mean you can actually host high level soccer.