cganuelas1995
Active member
I lived/worked in Sydney for a few months last year and really liked the tiered distance based system.
I don't like the variation in time, especially the hourly one.
No kidding; peak hours are peak hours for a reason. People shouldn't be punished for their jobs/classes starting and ending at the same time as everybody else's.
2015 Boardings:
Conventional Bus: 235,615,200 ** (+3.0%)
Community Shuttle: 5,366,400 (-4.7%)
SeaBus: 6,091,800 (+2.1%)
Expo/Millennium Line: 77,592,600 (+0.1%)
Canada Line: 40,972,300 ** (+1.8%)
West Coast Express: 2,648,800 (+0.9%)
Overall: 362,920,800 ** (+2.1%)
** = highest ridership ever recorded for the mode
Seems like a huge boost in ridership for Q4, as the Q3 data still showed negative growth or flat for pretty much all modes.
You're not punishing people for traveling during peak hours, you're rewarding people for traveling outside peak hours. It's a carrot, not a stick.People shouldn't be punished for their jobs/classes starting and ending at the same time as everybody else's.
You're not punishing people for traveling during peak hours, you're rewarding people for traveling outside peak hours. It's a carrot, not a stick.![]()
imo, there shouldn't be different fares for peak and non peak hours. Fares should be the same regardless the time of the day so it's simple and straightforward. There would no need to for "carrot and stick" debate
Except there is. If you have everybody going at the same time, you need to provide extra vehicles that you wouldn't need if the demand was more spread out over the day. It also reduces overcrowding.
This is pure supply and demand. When there is high demand, the price should be higher, when it's lower, the price should be lower.
Yeah life's a bitch.Peak hour exists mostly because (almost) all jobs end at roughly the same time - so, riders are basically getting dinged extra for having the wrong job or the wrong shift.
Might be a good idea.
I'm still very skeptical that our current peak hour ridership is at all affected by the off-peak fares after 6:30. First, people don't have that much flexibility. And second, those with standard 9-5 jobs taking transit probably have monthly passes that avoid this. Charging separate rates depending on the time only hurts spur-of-the-moment transit trips.
I wonder the same thing. Lacking empirical evidence, I don't feel comfortable guessing about the impact (or not) of off-peak discounts.
I do agree about the impact on unplanned trips. Forcing travellers to make decisions about how they will travel is a huge disincentive to taking transit. You might say that people won't stop to think: but incentives only produce efficiencies if they do. Once they do, they may choose not take transit at all. The burden of comparing alternatives can be disincentive enough.
Cars benefit from thoughtless travel. There's gas in the tank, so you just go, without thinking about the costs. When drivers do think about costs, they over-compensate by doing perverse things like spending more on gas to avoid bridge tolls.
For me, the biggest benefit of Compass is that it is like gas in the tank. There's no need to count change or even think about money. Introduce differential pricing and suddenly there's no gas in the tank: there's a price to be paid, a bit of money to be carefully weighed against the convenience of travel.
If we want people to take transit, we want them to focus on where they want to go, not how. We just want them to tap, and go. People say they want computers to Do What I Mean. What they want of transit is to Just Get Me There. They don't want to be bothered about the details. It should be thoughtless, automatic, a habit.
I understand the economic arguments about pricing to allocate a resource efficiently. But I am not at all convinced there's a benefit here. Price fairly by distance, like gas (because otherwise you discourage short trips), and no-one will blink. They will just tap, and go.
This is a very eloquent way of putting what I've been trying to say. Cars provide freedom, even if it comes with hidden costs. You get in, and you go. Transit should try and replicate this as much as possible. Forcing people to start calculating times, buses vs. trains and zone considerations just puts a burden on this freedom that drivers don't have to deal with.
This is a very eloquent way of putting what I've been trying to say. Cars provide freedom, even if it comes with hidden costs. You get in, and you go. Transit should try and replicate this as much as possible. Forcing people to start calculating times, buses vs. trains and zone considerations just puts a burden on this freedom that drivers don't have to deal with.